Which one was a better experience for you and was more memorable? I personally think GTA 4 was. I also thought GTA 4 multiplayer was better too.

Red Dead Redemption for me. But I wish the game would have been longer.

I was not a fan of the multiplayer though.

RDR was good but GTA wins hands down,,, RDR was basically gta painted over with a western paint brush

RDR for me since I thought gta got kinda repetive and I just liked rdr more overall, especially the time period and location it was set in compared to gta.

Red Dead Redemption !

red dead redempition. though i will say that I liked gta4s characters better.

For me RdR

I really enjoyed red dead. I haven't played the newest gta, maybe i'll get it on pc if its on sale at steam