Simple this, which one do you think will score the highest metacritic average?

Currently, it's;

Sonic Colours-

Sonic 4- 82% (interesting to note that the Wii version has the highest metacritic ^.^)

Sonic Free riders

I'm gonna say, bizzarely, sonic colours. What do you think?

Out of your list, Sonic 4 on the Wii. But I think the HD version will score higher though.

Perhaps, but I feel the opposite- I feel the HD ones will either score the same or lower, simply because it's not as appealing for the HD consoles and I also don't thin the controls are as suited.

I reckon Sonic 4 will be 80%

Sonic Colours 88%

Sonic Free Riders 65%

Perhaps.

But I don't expect Sonic Colors to be that good :O

I hope Sonic Colors... Sonic 4 is ok but not great.. Sonic's acceleration is strange and it's waaay too easy... I finished in about a hour..

It could really go either way. Sonic 4 could become a critical darling much as Megaman 9 and 10 did, and for similar reasons, while Sonic Colors could run into the same difficulties as recent console Sonics

Or the opposite could happen, that Sonic Colors will finally be the one that gets it right (there doesn't seem to be anything wrong with it, anyway. This late in the Sonic Cycle, we would have known if there were crazier gimmicks than the Wisps, which seem to be well-implemented), while Sonic 4 will end up looking mediocre compared to Sonics 1-3, given that Dimps has always made good Sonic games, but never outstanding ones

I feel as though Sonic Colours looks the better, it looks to be the Mario Galaxy of Sonic games, and that's good.

If you look at IGN's review, and some early reviews of the Iphone version, you'll se it's too short for the price, too easy and the animation is a bit buggy. Not looking good, whereas previews of Sonic Colours are overwhelmingly positive. It MAY just break into 90% territory...

Pretty much sums up what I think, the latter paragraph

Or, at least I hope.

Seems as though Sonic COLOURS takes an early lead, as expected :)

I think Sonic Colours will be slightly higher, but it could easily be either