The basic premise is to rate the avatar above you, leaving a summary and a final score out of 10. Of course this may depend on opinion, however you will need to have a suitable reason why you like/dislike it. "I dislike this avatar because it is stupid" (or anything along those lines) is not suitable.

I like your avatar since Mario riding a Yoshi can only mean fun times:)

Overall 8.5

Mario look like is gonna do a Street Fighter or Mortal Kombat move. Cool

9.0

8.5

Pretty neat if I do say.  Megaman Zero right?

Also, I don't hold against anyone who gives my avatar a low score.. since havent found a girl I liked for me avatar.

I give your avatar a 10 for you being so humble, and she's cute.

This avatar is slightly bland, however it has some manga elements to it. Overall score: 8/10

7/10 for cropping a Mario Image.

8 for being a bad clown same for the avatar