By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General - Mafia Round 20 Game Thread

there has to be a mistake. There has to be a mafia with a town name and same with the SK. There just has to be.



Around the Network
theprof00 said:
darthdevidem01 said:

That's not what I'm saying at all. His question was "are these people the name-claimed lying"

It's suspicious because the question wasn't "are the people who nameclaimed lying". He made a list of 5 people and wrote their name claims and asked if any were lying. He is supposed to get yes/no answers, but said his info said "zero". Another slip. Let me paint a scenario for you. Both Homer and I nameclaim on day 3. What question does vette ask? You see, he asked for five names. If he gets a "yes, someone is lying" then what? The SMART way to do it is to ask simply if one person is lying, not FIVE!!

Also, why didn't he just ask if I was lying when I said I was pro-town? We all went through it. We all said if we were pro-town or not. Why didn't he just ask that about myself or Homer.

My point is, we were already the ones he wanted to put the blame on. That's why he didn't do any of that. It just makes no sense.

Secondly, he called my name "a safe fake nameclaim". What shit is that? Everyone already claimed name except for vette, and I know that at least 2 players are kefka and ultimecia. Why? WHY? There are literally hundreds of names to pick from. Why would I choose a side-character from ff1? I could be zidane, bartz, vaan etc... the accusation is derisive insinuation. He's trying to make my truth seem like a scheme.

ok I get what you mean about Vetteman now.

No you say Vetteman is trying to make your truth seem like a scheme, thats fine he might be, but you were also calling his behaviour very "scummy" too....you had both latched on to eachother. But now you think Vett isn't scum after all?

He called your name safe claim just because it wasn't a popular character so wasn't likely to be used.....meaning the chances of your roleclaim being challenged were close to zero. Do you see why he thinks your roleclaim is "safe"......I am not supporting his accusation BTW.

Homer just confessed, so he's at least one of the mafia. And yes it does look like he's trying to get me lynched and I'll tell you why. Because I'm unkillable, and he probably learned that last night.

Your unkillable...WHAT! Why didn't you say earlier? What was stopping you from telling us this one thing earlier?

The fact that I'm still here arguing should tell you I'm not gone yet. However, heroes also see the good in people. And right now all I see are people playing very badly. You guys fell for FFs move to dsister. You guys are falling for this, and you fell for Homer when he called himself a protagonist. Seriously, I don't want to leave, because I like the themes and the game, but I really want to play on a forum that actually treats these games with respect and puts an effort into it.

This is my first game so I don't know how you play this while treating the game with respect. What do you mean people aren't treating the game with respect?

Anyway to continue our discussion tell me what you think we should do now.....you are pretty much safe since your @unkillable@ and I'm assuming your telling the truth for now and Metal Gear_94 might die tonight (his sibling died..). Are you suspicious of anyone else?







All hail the KING, Andrespetmonkey

theprof00 said:

Also, I'm not saying anything to indict vette, but you should know darth, terra worked for kefka at one point.

And it's also funny that she has a move called trance, because vette has you all in a trance

True that she did. 

_______

BTW if your "unkillable" is that a power you can only use a few times or is it permanent? It can't possibly be permanent...



All hail the KING, Andrespetmonkey

darthdevidem01 said:

True that she did. 

_______

BTW if your "unkillable" is that a power you can only use a few times or is it permanent? It can't possibly be permanent...

I'm not unlynchable though.



Vote: Homer_Simpson

Might as well get a Mafia out of the game, right?



Click this button, you know you want to!  [Subscribe]

Watch me on YouTube!

http://www.youtube.com/user/TheRadishBros

~~~~ Mario Kart 8 drove far past my expectations! Never again will I doubt the wheels of a Monster Franchise! :0 ~~~~

Around the Network
theprof00 said:
darthdevidem01 said:

True that she did. 

_______

BTW if your "unkillable" is that a power you can only use a few times or is it permanent? It can't possibly be permanent...

I'm not unlynchable though.

oh-kay

But why didn't you tell us this before? Like in day 2 or something? You'd have no proof but it would be handy to know this.



All hail the KING, Andrespetmonkey

Can the person who has made Homer forcefully "lynch himself" come out and tell us who they are?

Once that person's tells us who they are I'll go ahead and vote for homer.



All hail the KING, Andrespetmonkey

darthdevidem01 said:

ok I get what you mean about Vetteman now.

No you say Vetteman is trying to make your truth seem like a scheme, thats fine he might be, but you were also calling his behaviour very "scummy" too....you had both latched on to eachother. But now you think Vett isn't scum after all?

I changed my mind. I believe vette is town because of my cryptic information, but I am also hesitant to believe it. All I know is vette cannot be right, but he made a move against me making me think he's scum. And everything I say, he says is scum. He wants me lynched, but for what reason I don't know. At first I thought he was scum, but after reviewing what he did last game, there is ALSO the possibility that he's making a very basic mistake in that he assumes everyone that has claimed town and isn't lying isn't a mafia. This is under the assumption that good ff character = pro-town.

He called your name safe claim just because it wasn't a popular character so wasn't likely to be used.....meaning the chances of your roleclaim being challenged were close to zero. Do you see why he thinks your roleclaim is "safe"......I am not supporting his accusation BTW.

I would agree with him in any other situation.

But the fact is that there are many main characters I could have picked from if I were a mafia. If I were smart, I would have picked a high profile character.

Just to play along, I would know Vaan is most likely not in the game because dtewi hates vaan. I would stay away from zidane, because ff9 is dtewis favorite ff. Basch from 12 would be a good one, because he's "safe" and if I was investigated I could potentially claim that I was a miller (a townie who upon investigation comes up mafia). I could also claim a summon like alexander, or even boko the chocobo and claimed that I couldn't read, so that's why my messages were cryptic (if I were really desperate).

It's not my fault that my character is an unpopular one. I didn't pick it!

 

Your unkillable...WHAT! Why didn't you say earlier? What was stopping you from telling us this one thing earlier?

I'm only unkillable, not unlynchable.

This is my first game so I don't know how you play this while treating the game with respect. What do you mean people aren't treating the game with respect?

I mean people that pop in for 10 minutes a day, skim through the posts and bandwagon onto what other people are saying. It's frustrating. I like how Hat plays. He's very psychological, and makes a lot of gambles. However, he falls for the pity card so easily.

Basically, what vette is doing. Coming in, askign a couple questions and leaving. Relying on his power/role information more than anything else, and not taking the time to think of possibilities.

Anyway to continue our discussion tell me what you think we should do now.....you are pretty much safe since your @unkillable@ and I'm assuming your telling the truth for now and Metal Gear_94 might die tonight (his sibling died..). Are you suspicious of anyone else?

I think we should lynch homer, because he's the obvious mafia. However, now that we know who he is, we should really be looking at everyone else as well. I KNOW that there are mafia hiding under town names. It could be the moogle, it could be aeris. At this point, what I'm thinking is kill Homer, kill j0, and have vette investigate every person throughout the days asking specifically "Is X lying" using the information provided by every single person saying "I'm a protagonist".



darthdevidem01 said:
theprof00 said:
darthdevidem01 said:

True that she did. 

_______

BTW if your "unkillable" is that a power you can only use a few times or is it permanent? It can't possibly be permanent...

I'm not unlynchable though.

oh-kay

But why didn't you tell us this before? Like in day 2 or something? You'd have no proof but it would be handy to know this.

Because if I'm a target for the mafia they will try to kill me and fail, saving the town a night kill. I've written to Heph earlier that I would see him on day 9. That was a hint that I would survive that long. Because I'm unkillable.

Earlier, I wrote that I had a theory why there was no mafia kill. It was because I was targeted. And it was probably because I was on to something.



darthdevidem01 said:

Can the person who has made Homer forcefully "lynch himself" come out and tell us who they are?

Once that person's tells us who they are I'll go ahead and vote for homer.

If homer targeted me last night, then I have a secret power that makes people do that if they target me.

Being that there is no mafia kill, I am pretty sure he targeted me.