Indeed.

Shatter is also out of place. I thought Critter Crunch and Fat Princess were better if we are to talk about downloadable games.

IGN sucks at making lists.

IGN Scores

Borderlands - 8.8

Demon's Souls - 9.4

Metacritic Scores

Borderlands - 84

Demon's Souls - 89

Pretty much a 5-6 point difference not only for IGN, but overall across all reviewers and they gave the spot to Borderlands. Such a shame IGN, such a shame.

Dear IGN,

Regards,

Darthdevidem01

Ready for the EPIC FAIL everyone?

Check IGN's list from last year.

#25 Flower
#24 MLB 09: The Show
#23 Valkyria Chronicles
#22 Demon's Souls
#21 Street Fighter IV
#20 Ratchet & Clank Future: A Crack in Time
#19 Super Stardust HD
#18 Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion
#17 Wipeout HD
#16 Dead Space
#15 Resistance: Fall of Man
#14 Warhawk
#13 Infamous
#12 Rock Band 2
#11 Burnout Paradise
#10 Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2
#9 Batman: Arkham Asylum
#8 BioShock
#7 Killzone 2
#6 Uncharted: Drake's Fortune
#5 Fallout 3
#4 Grand Theft Auto IV
#3 LittleBigPlanet
#2 Uncharted 2
#1 Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots

MGS4 magically got worse than Fallout 3 while Fallout magically got better than LBP. Borderlands used to not be good enough while Demon's Souls was, now Demon's Souls isn't good enough but Borderlands is.

IGN fails so hard, lol.

I understand that opinions change over time, but that much? I guess it has to do with New Vegas being right around the corner.

What really pleasently suprised me was inFamous at #5. Totally agree with that.

Dear IGN,

Regards,

Darthdevidem01

So...

5 - Infamous

4 - LBP

3 - RDR

2 - Fallout 3

1 - Uncharted 2

At least the first place is fair.

I seriously think they wanted to downplay the exclusives

Dear IGN,

You upset me greatly.

Regards,

The Penetrator

i own 13 of 25 and i still don't have RDR, MDR, and GOW3 witch i will buy in the near future!