We just had one of these a few months ago, after Uncharted 2 came out I believe.  Odd that they're already doing another.

This list is weird.  Flower and A Crack in Time are criminally low, and Dead Space and Shatter are unusually high, and it looks like Warhawk and Infamous won't make the list at all.

I'm liking Killzone 2 at #6.  It seems it's still considered the best FPS on ps3 by sites like IGN and GameSpot.  I'm going to assume Uncharted 2 will be #1, with LittleBigPlanet at #2 or #3.  Hopefully Demon's Souls will be in there as well.  It's either top five or not on the list at all at this point.  =x  It's my favorite ps3 game after LBP though, so it totally deserves one of those last spots.

Not sure what the other two games might be.  Red Dead Redemption?  Would be surprised to see it get that high. Fallout 3?  Hard to see it above God of War and Metal Gear Solid, personally.

Edit:

Here's their last list:

#25 Flower
#24 MLB 09: The Show
#23 Valkyria Chronicles
#22 Demon's Souls
#21 Street Fighter IV
#20 Ratchet & Clank Future: A Crack in Time
#19 Super Stardust HD
#18 Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion
#17 Wipeout HD
#16 Dead Space
#15 Resistance: Fall of Man
#14 Warhawk
#13 Infamous
#12 Rock Band 2
#11 Burnout Paradise
#10 Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2
#9 Batman: Arkham Asylum
#8 BioShock
#7 Killzone 2
#6 Uncharted: Drake's Fortune
#5 Fallout 3
#4 Grand Theft Auto IV
#3 LittleBigPlanet
#2 Uncharted 2
#1 Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots

MGS4 has fallen to ninth, and titles like Warhawk and Infamous fell clear of the map.  Given Demon's Souls' position last time, I guess it just didn't make the list this time around either, which is disappointing.  The original Uncharted also fell considerably.  It looks like it's the same group of people voting this time around, and it's funny their opinions have changed so much in half a year.

I also find it funny that Modern Warfare 2 completely fell of the list, while the original Modern Warfare has reappeared at #17.

10. God of War III

9. Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots (ehh...)

8. Grand Theft Auto IV

7. Batman: Arkham Asylum

6. Killzone 2

Ok.....Killzone 2 being so high makes me realize even more at what point CoD4 is too low.

Edit: Too slow :(

10: GOW3

9: MGS4

8: GTAIV

7: Batman: Arkham Asylum

6: KZ2

edit: too slow as well ;-p

There's something really odd. Games like MW2, The Orange Box, Bioshock, OBLIVION (OMG) won't make it.

Uncharted 2, LittleBigPlanet, Fallout 3, Red Dead Redemption will be part of the top 5. Not sure about the other one. I'm thinking they will put Demon's Souls (great game that I liked but I do believe some people are overrating it because it's exclusive).

piece of crap list is crap

I don't understand... really I mean. I think for them they should just rank it according to the scores they gave it. Or rescind their original reviews and say it was incorrect.

It's just based on their opinions. If you check out the link for last years list you can see this at the beginning:

Last year, we took a vote and came up with our picks for the Top 25 PS3 games at that time (the article went up early this January). That list is below for your reference. A few things to note as to why the 2010 version is different:

point taken. As I wouldn't have even rated FFX in my top 50 favorite games until 2 years ago when I played it again.

However, it shows how meaningless these short term lists are. But they entertain so I guess they have meaning.

Well so far I own all but 2 of these games and one of them I own Street Fighter 4 just missing Heavy Rain.

So far this is pretty decent even if the order is off. Of course Colin having shatter as his number 1 game obviously inflated its ranking. Flower is a great game and so are Super Stardust and Shatter but I do not believe that either of them are better than Infamous, Demon Souls, Bioshock, Resistance 2, which are likely not on the list.  

Personally I think Joe Danger is the best PSN game with Flower and Pixel Junk Shooter and Monsters being close. 

cant believe Uncharted 1 is # 14, I would think that would easily be in the top 10

@op, hey look we have the same sig almost.