they actually gave it a 9.4.... but as someone told me different people did this than necessarily did the review. Thus, all their lists is different. I mean, as a professional site IMO you need to have a consistent viewpoint. Yes it should fluctuate some, but if you always change your mind it it looks like you don't know what your talking about imo.

(Yes I know time changes views on game... but jesus. Demon Soul's in no way aged badly imo for the short time its been around. I appreciate it more. Though it was always one of my favs)

the game was probably to hard

i piss my pants every time i play it. thats why im level 11.

i only looked at part of it and was glad to see dead space get a spot. 

Valkyria Chronicles and Demon's Souls also deserve a spot on that list but I didn't see either (though I didn't see the complete list.

inFamous ahead of MGS4 and GoW III? Are you shitting me IGN?

Worst. list. EVAR. And for the first time ever, I can say that statement is no exaggeration.

*insert epic fail gif/facepalm jpeg*

This list serves their purpose of getting them hits (like all of their lists do).  I don't care what they say.  Valkyria Chronicles is the best PS3 game and possibly this gen's best game.  Uncharted 2 is gonna win this thing even though I only played through it once on normal and never played it again.  It's the popular choice.  I guess everybody has different opinions about what is good.  Maybe it's good enough to just make the list.

In 1991, many reviewers put Sonic the Hedgehog 1 over Super Mario World as game of the year.  It takes time for impressions of a game to settle.  Some games age better than others.  Sometimes the flashy things that make a particular game stand out fail to impress after a while.  And sometimes, an improved sequel makes an original game a lot less impressive (like MGS Rising may make MGS4 look less unique).  Lots of factors to consider.  Plus, IGN fails on purpose for controversy.  They just want the hits.  A good debate will provide that.

Oh I know. If I made the list Uncharted 2 wouldn't even be in the Top 5.

LBP would be top of my list, too, and I also fully expect LBP2 to slot in right at number 1 for me.  Heck, it's the only game I've pre-ordered in ages and I can't wait to get to grips with the editor plus play the levels with my kids.

I hope you preordered the Collector's Edition with the bookends and Sackboy plushie.