By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sony - ign's best 25 ps3 games.

cmeese47 said:
dunno001 said:
binary solo said:

No Demon's Souls in the top 25 is a serious deficiency in the list. There are other deficiencies, but that's the main one.

This post speaks the truth. Of course, it would also require IGN to know what a good game is... which is something they fail on a regular basis...


Not true they gave it a 9 but it should be in the list

they actually gave it a 9.4.... but as someone told me different people did this than necessarily did the review. Thus, all their lists is different. I mean, as a professional site IMO you need to have a consistent viewpoint. Yes it should fluctuate some, but if you always change your mind it it looks like you don't know what your talking about imo.

(Yes I know time changes views on game... but jesus. Demon Soul's in no way aged badly imo for the short time its been around. I appreciate it more. Though it was always one of my favs)



Around the Network

the game was probably to hard



cmeese47 said:

the game was probably to hard


i piss my pants every time i play it. thats why im level 11.



Being in 3rd place never felt so good

i only looked at part of it and was glad to see dead space get a spot. 

Valkyria Chronicles and Demon's Souls also deserve a spot on that list but I didn't see either (though I didn't see the complete list.



inFamous ahead of MGS4 and GoW III? Are you shitting me IGN?

Worst. list. EVAR. And for the first time ever, I can say that statement is no exaggeration.

*insert epic fail gif/facepalm jpeg*



Around the Network

This list serves their purpose of getting them hits (like all of their lists do).  I don't care what they say.  Valkyria Chronicles is the best PS3 game and possibly this gen's best game.  Uncharted 2 is gonna win this thing even though I only played through it once on normal and never played it again.  It's the popular choice.  I guess everybody has different opinions about what is good.  Maybe it's good enough to just make the list.



Euphoria14 said:

Ready for the EPIC FAIL everyone?

Check IGN's list from last year.

#25 Flower
#24 MLB 09: The Show
#23 Valkyria Chronicles
#22 Demon's Souls
#21 Street Fighter IV
#20 Ratchet & Clank Future: A Crack in Time
#19 Super Stardust HD
#18 Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion
#17 Wipeout HD
#16 Dead Space
#15 Resistance: Fall of Man
#14 Warhawk
#13 Infamous
#12 Rock Band 2
#11 Burnout Paradise
#10 Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2
#9 Batman: Arkham Asylum
#8 BioShock
#7 Killzone 2
#6 Uncharted: Drake's Fortune
#5 Fallout 3
#4 Grand Theft Auto IV
#3 LittleBigPlanet
#2 Uncharted 2
#1 Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots

 

MGS4 magically got worse than Fallout 3 while Fallout magically got better than LBP. Borderlands used to not be good enough while Demon's Souls was, now Demon's Souls isn't good enough but Borderlands is.

IGN fails so hard, lol.

I understand that opinions change over time, but that much? I guess it has to do with New Vegas being right around the corner.



In 1991, many reviewers put Sonic the Hedgehog 1 over Super Mario World as game of the year.  It takes time for impressions of a game to settle.  Some games age better than others.  Sometimes the flashy things that make a particular game stand out fail to impress after a while.  And sometimes, an improved sequel makes an original game a lot less impressive (like MGS Rising may make MGS4 look less unique).  Lots of factors to consider.  Plus, IGN fails on purpose for controversy.  They just want the hits.  A good debate will provide that.



d21lewis said:
Euphoria14 said:

Ready for the EPIC FAIL everyone?

Check IGN's list from last year.

#25 Flower
#24 MLB 09: The Show
#23 Valkyria Chronicles
#22 Demon's Souls
#21 Street Fighter IV
#20 Ratchet & Clank Future: A Crack in Time
#19 Super Stardust HD
#18 Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion
#17 Wipeout HD
#16 Dead Space
#15 Resistance: Fall of Man
#14 Warhawk
#13 Infamous
#12 Rock Band 2
#11 Burnout Paradise
#10 Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2
#9 Batman: Arkham Asylum
#8 BioShock
#7 Killzone 2
#6 Uncharted: Drake's Fortune
#5 Fallout 3
#4 Grand Theft Auto IV
#3 LittleBigPlanet
#2 Uncharted 2
#1 Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots

 

MGS4 magically got worse than Fallout 3 while Fallout magically got better than LBP. Borderlands used to not be good enough while Demon's Souls was, now Demon's Souls isn't good enough but Borderlands is.

IGN fails so hard, lol.

I understand that opinions change over time, but that much? I guess it has to do with New Vegas being right around the corner.



In 1991, many reviewers put Sonic the Hedgehog 1 over Super Mario World as game of the year.  It takes time for impressions of a game to settle.  Some games age better than others.  Sometimes the flashy things that make a particular game stand out fail to impress after a while.  And sometimes, an improved sequel makes an original game a lot less impressive (like MGS Rising may make MGS4 look less unique).  Lots of factors to consider.  Plus, IGN fails on purpose for controversy.  They just want the hits.  A good debate will provide that.

Oh I know. If I made the list Uncharted 2 wouldn't even be in the Top 5.



iPhone = Great gaming device. Don't agree? Who cares, because you're wrong.

Currently playing:

Final Fantasy VI (iOS), Final Fantasy: Record Keeper (iOS) & Dragon Quest V (iOS)     

    

Got a retro room? Post it here!

Euphoria14 said:

My personal Top 5 for PS3 is - (This is based only on what I have played)

5.) Uncharted 2  

4.) Oblivion

3.) Fallout 3

2.) Demon's Souls

1.) LittleBigPlanet 

 

Number 1 will soon be replaced by LBP2 with LBP being eliminated since LBP2 supports everything I have in LBP. 

 

Edit - Need to find something to replace Uncharted 2 with actually. While the series is great I find them to be games I can't bring myself to play more than once, hence the reason I never bought either of them, only rented.

LBP would be top of my list, too, and I also fully expect LBP2 to slot in right at number 1 for me.  Heck, it's the only game I've pre-ordered in ages and I can't wait to get to grips with the editor plus play the levels with my kids.



Try to be reasonable... its easier than you think...

Reasonable said:
Euphoria14 said:

My personal Top 5 for PS3 is - (This is based only on what I have played)

5.) Uncharted 2  

4.) Oblivion

3.) Fallout 3

2.) Demon's Souls

1.) LittleBigPlanet 

 

Number 1 will soon be replaced by LBP2 with LBP being eliminated since LBP2 supports everything I have in LBP. 

 

Edit - Need to find something to replace Uncharted 2 with actually. While the series is great I find them to be games I can't bring myself to play more than once, hence the reason I never bought either of them, only rented.

LBP would be top of my list, too, and I also fully expect LBP2 to slot in right at number 1 for me.  Heck, it's the only game I've pre-ordered in ages and I can't wait to get to grips with the editor plus play the levels with my kids.


I hope you preordered the Collector's Edition with the bookends and Sackboy plushie.



iPhone = Great gaming device. Don't agree? Who cares, because you're wrong.

Currently playing:

Final Fantasy VI (iOS), Final Fantasy: Record Keeper (iOS) & Dragon Quest V (iOS)     

    

Got a retro room? Post it here!