Well your plan in effectively ending the SK if you're right with your list. I can go with that. What I was questioning was the idea of guessing and possibly getting pro-towns killed in the process. 

I read your other post and we still get two people killed: 

lynch one - he's dead
treat him - he survives
mafia killes the other - he's dead

So it is indeed two kills. 

I wasn't trying to lure them out >.> I even said "but then the mafia would go for them." Which pretty much negated the paragraph implying that it won't happen. 

I want to lynch Nikells and treat Heph.

If you guys have anything else to add, please, do so. However my mind is set on this plan

Vote: Nikells

Remember my scum list, I'm pretty sure I've nailed most of the scum there since not  many put up an argument against it. I say this because I doubt I'll live through the night. If I do live and we do get Kratos, hopefully you SOBS will stop doubting me finally.

I suggest everyone jump on the lynch plan.

how do you know if he wants to remain scum or not? I thought you hadnt found him yet?

hmm, I mean, this is a big risk no?

were lynching someone whose username ends with S, which means we have a 1 in 3 chance of them being the SK, but a 2 in 3 chance that they arent the SK and then its  a case of, if they arent the SK, what are they and how valuable would they have been to the town (assuming we lynch them)?

perhaps you have further reason to specifically suspect Nikells, if so, im gonna need to hear it before voting.

facepalm* der der der because he hasn't come forward yet! I offered to help him many times and here we are 5plus real days into the game and he still hasn't come forward.

And wtf @ the second part!? of course I didn't find him. What the hell do you think I've been posting like crazy for the last 24 hours has been for  -_-

However after tonight, He'll be found.

Take a fighting game for example.

Player A knocks player B onto the floor.

Player B has two options. rise with a kick or rise with a block. 90% of the time people kick, because all they risk is a jab.

Player B rises with a kick, the counter to this is to do a jab when player B rises.

This is yomi 1.

yomi 2 follows:

Player B knows player A is going to punch him when he gets up, and so instead rises with a block with the intent to block the incoming jab and throw a roundhouse.

Player A knows player B is going to throw up a block to counter the rising kick counter. So player A does a 3 step powerful grab when he gets up.

yomi 3: Player B knows player A is going to grab and so does a grab escape right after rising and prepares a combo.

Player A knows player player B is expecting a grab, so does a charged up punch that does a lot of damage.

Then it repeats because the counter is a rising kick.

okay, its just some of your posts confuse me, lol

I would point out however, that even if he wanted to come forward, it would be a risk for him to do so as it would make him a target for the mafia would it not?

unless you are saying that your role also gives him nightkill immunity or that he has it already (if the later, how do we know that?)

Alright: so you think I'm the SK but you want to lynch me rather than cure me now?
That doesn't sound like a psychiatrist to me.

Two things:

1) I'm not.
2) You know it.

because the odds of him being mafia if not SK is higher than any of the other three. So I'd rather risk him dying. Nothing wrong with getting a scum out of the way.

I do admit the evidence on him isn't so ground breaking. I'm using past game behavior for scum hunting.

Also I honestly feel like shit wanting to lynch him after he defended me so much :(

Sorry nikells. It's for the good of the town.

Vote Nikells