By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - Mafia Round 18 Game Thread

Gnizmo said:

 This lurker thing seems to have turned into a bit of a witch hunt at this point. If it is really that big a deal then just vote for Falcon and be done with it. At this point nothing real has even been brought up save for one post from stefl. I am going to go ahead and assume none of the other roles turned up anything juicy.


The problem is that I don't see anything concrete enough to go on otherwise: we need information to work with, and without a cop telling us "guilty" or something similar, posts are all we have to go on.  And apparently several people don't feel any real need to post, so... What would you recommend instead?

c03n3nj0 said:


The problem with that is... we have no way to prove it. It's not a good idea to lynch someone without any good proof behind it. 

True, and to be blunt I'd retract my vote if it seemed like a lynch was likely to happen (guess who just called his own bluff... =^/ ).  But like I said, what are our alternatives?  Vote no lynch, and hope we get more info overnight?  Let the day drag on until nen times us out again?  Other?  I'm being serious; what do people propose doing instead?



Around the Network
dsister said:
Stefl, I know your intentions were good. But you've doomed us both.

Tonight the mafia won't even think twice of killing me. If they have a roleblocker then you'll be useless as well.

I can see why you did it, and why you announced it, but you did it really prematurely. You should have only said something if I was closed to being lynched.

What some of you seem to forget is that I am actually pretty decent at this game and can talk my way out of a lot of stuff. There hasn't even been a point in this game where I've even felt remotely like I was going to get lynched. No one was even really that suspicious of me. All I've gotten are FoS's, which are completely useless.

This is kind of one of the reasons why I voted for Vetteman. Because posts like his, nonames, and a lesser extent Godofwar_3ever's sometimes get responses from people...

I'll help you out for now Dsis...

I am Cyrax, I am pro-town, during night I have two things I can do

Meditate: Using my ninja-cybernetic powers I can meditate and reach out and it will be revealed to me who is evil (however if there are too many people around me I cannot concentrate - this is why I said no tea parties at my house, I must have been targeted by 2 or more people because I got nothing back)

Energy Net: - I can choose to throw my energy net which will ensnare anyone who comes to me at night thus rendering their actions against me null

The reason I am sharing this now is I think there are only a couple mafia left (4 to be exact and probably an SK).  Now the Mafia has a conundrum, do they target me, dsister or stef now, if they target me I can net them and they will fail whatever they were going to do to me.  If we have a doctor I would suggest to protect dsister or stef for tonight.

I will not say which ability I am going to use tonight, but if you are pro-town, stay away from me in case I decide to use my meditate.



Unicorns ARE real - They are just fat, grey and called Rhinos

How exactly did that help me?????? -_-

 

Message to all players!

There is a time and a place for a role claim. This is not that time...



Sig thanks to Saber! :D 

noname2200 said:
Gnizmo said:

 This lurker thing seems to have turned into a bit of a witch hunt at this point. If it is really that big a deal then just vote for Falcon and be done with it. At this point nothing real has even been brought up save for one post from stefl. I am going to go ahead and assume none of the other roles turned up anything juicy.


The problem is that I don't see anything concrete enough to go on otherwise: we need information to work with, and without a cop telling us "guilty" or something similar, posts are all we have to go on.  And apparently several people don't feel any real need to post, so... What would you recommend instead?

c03n3nj0 said:


The problem with that is... we have no way to prove it. It's not a good idea to lynch someone without any good proof behind it. 

True, and to be blunt I'd retract my vote if it seemed like a lynch was likely to happen (guess who just called his own bluff... =^/ ).  But like I said, what are our alternatives?  Vote no lynch, and hope we get more info overnight?  Let the day drag on until nen times us out again?  Other?  I'm being serious; what do people propose doing instead?

I was just talking about voting for Mako with the reasons you gave... and also it's pointless to pressure someone who's not even online in the first place.

 I agree with you that this is one of the only things we can do right now. The more people post, the more information we can get out of it. Not a lot of people are posting. 

My bet is, we look for someone who hasn't been offline, and has chosen not to post. We'll get the excuse of "there was nothing going on!" but well, that's people's faults.



 Tag (Courtesy of Fkusumot) "If I'm posting in this thread then it's probally a spam thread."                               

noname2200 said:
Gnizmo said:

 This lurker thing seems to have turned into a bit of a witch hunt at this point. If it is really that big a deal then just vote for Falcon and be done with it. At this point nothing real has even been brought up save for one post from stefl. I am going to go ahead and assume none of the other roles turned up anything juicy.


The problem is that I don't see anything concrete enough to go on otherwise: we need information to work with, and without a cop telling us "guilty" or something similar, posts are all we have to go on.  And apparently several people don't feel any real need to post, so... What would you recommend instead?

c03n3nj0 said:


The problem with that is... we have no way to prove it. It's not a good idea to lynch someone without any good proof behind it. 

True, and to be blunt I'd retract my vote if it seemed like a lynch was likely to happen (guess who just called his own bluff... =^/ ).  But like I said, what are our alternatives?  Vote no lynch, and hope we get more info overnight?  Let the day drag on until nen times us out again?  Other?  I'm being serious; what do people propose doing instead?


I don't think not lynching is a good idea, since later on the lurkers will just come up again, when we could really use the lynch to effectively kill mafia AND there is still a probability that we might lynch a mafia lurker... On the other hand nen could modkill some of the hardcore lurkers again...

I think we should put pressure on someone that has been online recently to force them to post...



Around the Network
dsister said:

How exactly did that help me?????? -_-

 

Message to all players!

There is a time and a place for a role claim. This is not that time...


I said how it helped you :P  Now Mafia won't know who to attack, and also thinkin if we have a bus driver maybe he can swap you or stefl with one of the lurkers and have a doctor protect the other

IE: Bus driver swap dsister with a lurker, doctor protect stefl, that way if they target you, we kill a lurker (which we are tempted to do anyhow) and Stefl gets protection so he can investigate another tonight...

 



Unicorns ARE real - They are just fat, grey and called Rhinos

@ Tanstalas

That was completely unnecessary...



 Tag (Courtesy of Fkusumot) "If I'm posting in this thread then it's probally a spam thread."                               

Tanstalas said:
dsister said:

How exactly did that help me?????? -_-

 

Message to all players!

There is a time and a place for a role claim. This is not that time...


I said how it helped you :P  Now Mafia won't know who to attack, and also thinkin if we have a bus driver maybe he can swap you or stefl with one of the lurkers and have a doctor protect the other

IE: Bus driver swap dsister with a lurker, doctor protect stefl, that way if they target you, we kill a lurker (which we are tempted to do anyhow) and Stefl gets protection so he can investigate another tonight...

 

Look at it this way: now the mafia have one more chance of killing on of you than before where it was 50/50. Also, there's more than one faction, which increases the risk of you dying, and we don't know who they were going to target in the first place. And a possible serial killer. 

We have no idea if there even is a Bus Driver in the first place, not to mention which side the buus driver would be in.



 Tag (Courtesy of Fkusumot) "If I'm posting in this thread then it's probally a spam thread."                               

Tanstalas said:


I said how it helped you :P  Now Mafia won't know who to attack, and also thinkin if we have a bus driver maybe he can swap you or stefl with one of the lurkers and have a doctor protect the other

IE: Bus driver swap dsister with a lurker, doctor protect stefl, that way if they target you, we kill a lurker (which we are tempted to do anyhow) and Stefl gets protection so he can investigate another tonight...

 


Now that mafia know that you aren't the doctor. That just cuts Stefl's lifespan.

 

Also you should never tell people who to use their roles on. It just allows the mafia a chance to counter...



Sig thanks to Saber! :D 

I say discussions of the pro-town's night roles should never be discussed in the first place. 

So this ends here, ya hear? Don't tell the mafia what your plans are. (Unless it's a trick, then go ahead. )



 Tag (Courtesy of Fkusumot) "If I'm posting in this thread then it's probally a spam thread."