Agreed,  that wasnt a very smart thing to do Hephaestos.  That will be remembered later in the game and only come back to bite you.

YAY  5000  posts!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Well, now that you have expressed your thoughts, what are your thoughts for voting?

Your point was already discussed earlier by a few people.  We know that WoW is probably dead unless someone protects her tonight or she was false roleclaiming, or the mafia decide since they know who she is now they can just sit back and pick other people off for now, really she only has a 1 in 18 chance of getting Bison if she has that alternate win scenerio, odd's are on Bison's side (if we assume that by taking out Bison she wins/town wins)...

Anyhow, I don't know how much more information we are going to get out of this day, this day is already around 200 posts.. :)

Oh and gratz on 5k posts :P

My voting situation I am still pondering,  I thought a no vote would be best since there is a good possibilty of loosing multiple people tonight so another one would be really bad for the town unless we got lucky and nabbed a mafia.  

But I have started thinking of another possibility, what if the player who has Bison has a win situation as well,  which involves killing the player out to target him,  in this case WoW.    Would it be in the towns best interest to remove that chance?  

wow you guys crack me up... so i'm dumb for replying to a "vote just for fun" by a "vote because he voted for me :-p"  while there are already 9 out of 19 players who have voted no lynch...

Either I missunderstood the rule and everyone with votes gets lynched (i thought you needed a majority)

or you guys kind of missed a step in the whole process here.

in any case, it's odd that you two target me with the bad remark rather than FF for the initial "no reason vote"...one might think you're from the same group!

edit: gratz on 5k :p

And trying to throw suspicion on myself and Vette for just trying to warn you about something makes me even more curious about you

Unless it is his condition to kill Rose single-handedly, as in a night kill, lynching Rose will only help his cause. Because I'm thinking that in this case his win condition would be to have Rose dead, plain and simple. 

If that's what you meant then it's not a good idea.  

I'll Unvote No lynch since we're discussin' again.

I'm willing to admit that I voted Heph on pretty weak evidence, but it was hardly "no reason". 

And to be honest I shrugged off his revenge vote as a joke, because it was so ridiculously obvious.  Although his last post suspecting V94 and Tanstalas makes me wonder ...

I kind of agree that I wish we weren't in the position of WoW and the other people having their names exposed, but the fact is that we are, so we have to proceed from there.  And IMO there's not much more to lose if everyone does it, and considerable benefit to be had for the town if everyone does. 

And yeah, I didn't even realize he might be suggesting we lynch WoW to stop someone from killing him.  That seems ... counterproductive.  Even if Bison did have a specific win condition of killing Rose and not anyone else killing her, I don't think his winning would stop the town from winning the main game so why should we even care? 

LOL, - thats Mafia though, talk to much and you are a suspect, lurk and you are a suspect, do something a little strange and... you guessed it.. a suspect..

Really though, in 27 hours only 6 people in the game have posted...

SAK, Hephaestos, Vette, J0, you and myself..  where are the other 13?  And where *IS* Nikells?  Nikells has been on many times since game started but no posts...

Hatmoza, can you PM him again, maybe the first one got lost.  I would, but can't talk to other people about Mafia outside of the game.. or how many days until we find a replacement?  Been roughly 2.5 days since game started now, hasn't it?

I sent Nikells a reminder a couple hours ago. I'll post a link to the game on his wall.