I agree that DF was more special in some ways, but there were so many more wow moments in Uncharted 2, and it is still better than any other game ever.... I do really love that game

@akibafan, actually I missed somebody who did miss it out!

1. Dylan

2. Dylan

3. Dylan

4. Dylan

5. Dylan

6. Dylan

7. Dylan

8. Dylan

9. Dyaln

10. and Dylan,

 because i spit hot fire.

lol OT:

1: ioi 2

2: Killzone 2-  while it lasted

3. MAG- while it lasted

4. Battlefield Bad company- while it lasted

5. Uncharted 2

6. WipeOut HD Fury   

7. God of War 3

8. Little big Planet

9. inFAMOUS

10. WarHawk

honorable mentions; Fat Princess, Battlefield 1943, Resistance 2, Call od Duty World at War,  Hello Kitty Island Adventures<--- under rated title.                                                                                                                                                                               

Is #7 worringly low ? It wasn't even GOTY 2009 for me, KZ2 is.

Uncharted 2 easily could have been as high as #1 but....my experience with UC2 will explain everything.

First 4 chapters - boooooooooooooooring

From Nepal to Monastery - FUCK YES !

From Monastery to the End - meh.

If it started off with a bang and kept the same awesomeness towards the end, UC2 would have been my favourite PS3 game, no doubt about it.

Maybe its because UC2 started off slowly and GoW III began with a bang and maintained it through out the game till the end (although after a certain mind blowing HUGE boss battle it went slightly downhill, but finished just in time before it got "meh").

And epic scale helps too I guess.

Valkyria Chronicles
Metal Gear Solid 4
LittleBigPlanet
God Of War 3
Grand Theft Auto 4
Bioshock 2
Killzone 2
Heavy Rain
Ratchet & Clank : A Crack In Time
Resistance: Fall of Man

other nominations for the list are: Brutal Legend, Uncharted 2: Among Thieves, R&C: Tools of Destruction

Didn't beat Demon's Souls, Resistane 2 and Infamous yet.

My #1 would easily be Bioshock, but I only own the 360 version, i.e I can't include it on this list, as I haven't played the PS3 version. (The 2 versions are most probably pretty much identical, but screw it! Let's just say; here's my top 10 PS3 games minus Bioshock.)

Also, I'll only include 1 game per franchise.

10.  inFamous

9.   Assassin's Creed (AC 2 is way better, but again, I only own the 360 version... )

8.  Resident Evil 5

7.  Ratchet & Clank: Tools of Destruction

6.  Bioshock 2

5.  Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots

4.  Batman: Arkham Asylum

3.  God of War III

2.  Uncharted 2: Among Thieves

1.  LittleBigPlanet

1. Uncharted 2
2. RockBand 2
3. Demon's Souls
4. Oblivion
5. Uncharted
6. Infamous
7. MGS4
8. Resistance FOM
9. Valkyria Chronicles
10. Burnout Paradise

Honorable Mentions: GOW 3 and GOW Collection (excellent games...but not quite there), Assassin's Creed 2 (such an improvement over the crappy first), Bioshock (terrible final third though), Wipeout HD (too fucking hard)

1.) LittleBigPlanet
2.) Call of Duty 4
3.) Grand Theft Auto 4
4.) Uncharted Drakes Fortune
5.) Uncharted2
6.) Metal Gear Solid 4
7.) Call of Duty Modern Warfare 2
8.) Call of Duty World at War
9.) Resistance 2
10.) Motorstorm Pacific Rift

1. Heavy Rain
2. God of War III
3. Metal Gear Solid 4
4. LittleBigPlanet
5. inFamous
6. Killzone 2
7. Valkyria Chronicles
8. Uncharted 2
9. Resistance 2
10. Resistance Fall of Man

Wait here a second. You have Demons souls as number 3# yet you disclude Wipeout because of it's difficulty? I thought Demons souls was the hardest game on the PS tripple?