21 (Wii) Super Mario Galaxy

14 (Wii) Metroid Prime 3

9 (360) Mass Effect
9 (360) Bioshock

7 (DS) Dr. Kawashima's Brain Training 2 (+)

6 (Multi) The Orange Box
6 (PS2) Okami

5 (Multi) Rock Band (-)
5 (PS3) Rachet and Clank
5 (Wii) Wii Fit
5 (PC) Gears of War

4 (Multi) Call of Duty 4
4 (PC) Crysis
4 (PS2) God of War 2
4 (PC) Unreal Tournment 3
4 (PS3) Uncharted: Drake's Fortune

3 (PC) World in Conflict

1 (PS3) Heavenly Sword

DEAD (Wii) Resident Evil 4
DEAD (Wii) Super Paper Mario
DEAD (PS3) Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion
DEAD (Multi) Assassin Creed
DEAD (PS3) Ninja Gaiden Sigma
DEAD (360) Halo 3

Add +1 if you believe that game should be GOTY
and -1 if you believe that the game does not deserve to be GOTY

Add one and take one each time you vote
Vote once per hour MAX
You may add games that you dont see.... Games Valid Jan 1 2007 till Today

RolStoppable said: DMeisterJ said: Or maybe all of the games that I have listed are already below ten. My highest game has a seven. That'd need thirteen votes to tie it with SMG, provided no one brings those games down or SMG up. NO POINT. SO, I'd rather post about what I knew was going to happen anyway. I'm not saying SMG doesn't deserve to win, but Okami, Bioshock, Mass Effect, R&C, Rock Band, GOW2, THE ORANGE BOX, and uncharted need to be fifteen points behind. It should be a lot closer. All of these games are good. Already below ten? That comes as a surprise, considering that all games started at 5! If all the people, who complained about the Wii bias, had instead used their time to vote on their prefered games, this elimination game would not be that one sided.

 

My bad.  Even worse though.  All the good games are barely moving but SMG is leaps and bounds from where it started.

 

Wii Fit cant be on the list...its doesnt come out till Jan 2008 in USA. This is for the USA. Plus even if it came out Dec 30 2007 it shouldnt be on the list becuase we dont know if its any good yet. Hell it could suck.


20 (Wii) Super Mario Galaxy (-)

14 (Wii) Metroid Prime 3

9 (360) Mass Effect
9 (360) Bioshock

7 (DS) Dr. Kawashima's Brain Training 2
6 (Multi) Call of Duty 4 (+)
6 (Multi) The Orange Box
6 (PS2) Okami

5 (Multi) Rock Band
5 (PS3) Rachet and Clank
5 (PC) Gears of War


4 (PC) Crysis
4 (PS2) God of War 2
4 (PC) Unreal Tournment 3
4 (PS3) Uncharted: Drake's Fortune

3 (PC) World in Conflict

1 (PS3) Heavenly Sword

DEAD (Wii) Resident Evil 4
DEAD (Wii) Super Paper Mario
DEAD (PS3) Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion
DEAD (Multi) Assassin Creed
DEAD (PS3) Ninja Gaiden Sigma
DEAD (360) Halo 3

Add +1 if you believe that game should be GOTY
and -1 if you believe that the game does not deserve to be GOTY

Add one and take one each time you vote
Vote once per hour MAX
You may add games that you dont see.... Games Valid Jan 1 2007 till Today

20 (Wii) Super Mario Galaxy

14 (Wii) Metroid Prime 3

10 (360) Bioshock (+)

9 (360) Mass Effect

7 (DS) Dr. Kawashima's Brain Training 2
6 (Multi) Call of Duty 4
6 (Multi) The Orange Box
6 (PS2) Okami

5 (Multi) Rock Band
5 (PS3) Rachet and Clank
5 (PC) Gears of War


4 (PC) Crysis
4 (PS2) God of War 2
4 (PC) Unreal Tournment 3
4 (PS3) Uncharted: Drake's Fortune

3 (PC) World in Conflict

0 (PS3) Heavenly Sword (-)

DEAD (PS3) Heavenly Sword
DEAD (Wii) Resident Evil 4
DEAD (Wii) Super Paper Mario
DEAD (PS3) Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion
DEAD (Multi) Assassin Creed
DEAD (PS3) Ninja Gaiden Sigma
DEAD (360) Halo 3

Add +1 if you believe that game should be GOTY
and -1 if you believe that the game does not deserve to be GOTY

Add one and take one each time you vote
Vote once per hour MAX
You may add games that you dont see.... Games Valid Jan 1 2007 till Today

20 (Wii) Super Mario Galaxy

14 (Wii) Metroid Prime 3

10 (360) Bioshock

9 (360) Mass Effect

8 (DS) Dr. Kawashima's Brain Training 2 (+)

6 (Multi) The Orange Box
6 (PS2) Okami

5 (Multi) Rock Band
5 (PS3) Rachet and Clank
5 (PC) Gears of War
5 (Multi) Call of Duty 4 (-)

4 (PC) Crysis
4 (PS2) God of War 2
4 (PC) Unreal Tournment 3
4 (PS3) Uncharted: Drake's Fortune

3 (PC) World in Conflict

DEAD (PS3) Heavenly Sword
DEAD (Wii) Resident Evil 4
DEAD (Wii) Super Paper Mario
DEAD (PS3) Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion
DEAD (Multi) Assassin Creed
DEAD (PS3) Ninja Gaiden Sigma
DEAD (360) Halo 3

Add +1 if you believe that game should be GOTY
and -1 if you believe that the game does not deserve to be GOTY

Add one and take one each time you vote
Vote once per hour MAX
You may add games that you dont see.... Games Valid Jan 1 2007 till Today

Sicilian4391 said: Wii Fit cant be on the list...its doesnt come out till Jan 2008 in USA. This is for the USA. Plus even if it came out Dec 30 2007 it shouldnt be on the list becuase we dont know if its any good yet. Hell it could suck.

You changed the rules? Can we all change the rules or would you just like to announce the winner now? It doesn't matter if we know how good the game is, I mean really, have you played every game on the list? Have you voted for a game that you haven't played?

21 (Wii) Super Mario Galaxy (+)

14 (Wii) Metroid Prime 3

9 (360) Bioshock (-)
9 (360) Mass Effect

8 (DS) Dr. Kawashima's Brain Training 2

6 (Multi) The Orange Box
6 (PS2) Okami

5 (Multi) Rock Band
5 (PS3) Rachet and Clank
5 (PC) Gears of War
5 (Multi) Call of Duty 4

4 (PC) Crysis
4 (PS2) God of War 2
4 (PC) Unreal Tournment 3
4 (PS3) Uncharted: Drake's Fortune

3 (PC) World in Conflict

DEAD (PS3) Heavenly Sword
DEAD (Wii) Resident Evil 4
DEAD (Wii) Super Paper Mario
DEAD (PS3) Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion
DEAD (Multi) Assassin Creed
DEAD (PS3) Ninja Gaiden Sigma
DEAD (360) Halo 3

Add +1 if you believe that game should be GOTY
and -1 if you believe that the game does not deserve to be GOTY

Add one and take one each time you vote
Vote once per hour MAX
You may add games that you dont see.... Games Valid Jan 1 2007 till Today

21 (Wii) Super Mario Galaxy

15 (Wii) Metroid Prime 3 (+)

9 (360) Bioshock
9 (360) Mass Effect

8 (DS) Dr. Kawashima's Brain Training 2

6 (Multi) The Orange Box
6 (PS2) Okami

5 (Multi) Rock Band
5 (PS3) Rachet and Clank
5 (PC) Gears of War

4 (Multi) Call of Duty 4 (-)
4 (PC) Crysis
4 (PS2) God of War 2
4 (PC) Unreal Tournment 3
4 (PS3) Uncharted: Drake's Fortune

3 (PC) World in Conflict

DEAD (PS3) Heavenly Sword
DEAD (Wii) Resident Evil 4
DEAD (Wii) Super Paper Mario
DEAD (PS3) Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion
DEAD (Multi) Assassin Creed
DEAD (PS3) Ninja Gaiden Sigma
DEAD (360) Halo 3

Add +1 if you believe that game should be GOTY
and -1 if you believe that the game does not deserve to be GOTY

Add one and take one each time you vote
Vote once per hour MAX
You may add games that you dont see.... Games Valid Jan 1 2007 till Today

Okami was released last year ( and got game of the year from IGN, I think) Why is it on this list?

22 (Wii) Super Mario Galaxy (+)

15 (Wii) Metroid Prime 3

9 (360) Bioshock
9 (360) Mass Effect

8 (DS) Dr. Kawashima's Brain Training 2

6 (Multi) The Orange Box
6 (PS2) Okami

5 (Multi) Rock Band
5 (PS3) Rachet and Clank

4 (Multi) Call of Duty 4
4 (PC) Gears of War (-)
4 (PC) Crysis
4 (PS2) God of War 2
4 (PC) Unreal Tournment 3
4 (PS3) Uncharted: Drake's Fortune

3 (PC) World in Conflict

DEAD (PS3) Heavenly Sword
DEAD (Wii) Resident Evil 4
DEAD (Wii) Super Paper Mario
DEAD (PS3) Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion
DEAD (Multi) Assassin Creed
DEAD (PS3) Ninja Gaiden Sigma
DEAD (360) Halo 3

21 (Wii) Super Mario Galaxy (-)

15 (Wii) Metroid Prime 3

9 (360) Bioshock
9 (360) Mass Effect

8 (DS) Dr. Kawashima's Brain Training 2

7 (Multi) The Orange Box (+) (the cake is a lie)

6 (PS2) Okami

5 (Multi) Rock Band
5 (PS3) Rachet and Clank


4 (Multi) Call of Duty 4
4 (PC) Gears of War
4 (PC) Crysis
4 (PS2) God of War 2
4 (PC) Unreal Tournment 3
4 (PS3) Uncharted: Drake's Fortune

3 (PC) World in Conflict

DEAD (PS3) Heavenly Sword
DEAD (Wii) Resident Evil 4
DEAD (Wii) Super Paper Mario
DEAD (PS3) Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion
DEAD (Multi) Assassin Creed
DEAD (PS3) Ninja Gaiden Sigma
DEAD (360) Halo 3