This could be a good debate but probably not for this thread.  I would say there is unquestionably some music that is better than other music, and some movies that are better than other movies, however, I also understand what you are saying and agree with it to a point.

not going to happen

video games go far and beyond what art is doing , they incorporate every single medium of imagination, creation and execution.

and your comment about art cannot be compared to another piece of art and proclaimed better is not true art can be judged like anything else but its all subjective in the end, just like comparing graphics in a game , some people think UC2 is the best while others think something like flower or braid is more suited to there taste of whats "better".

look at the mona lisa or michealangelos david they are replicating the human form to its essence , so in videogames are we not taking that even further with technology , we are creating life like characters and worlds that do not exist in reality to me thats taking the "art" to a whole new level with the tools to make it a reality and the imagination needed to make it believeable. 

art is essentially the beginning and end of creation in my eyes , look at modern art some of it is so basic like a few colored squares or lines some people will argue that it is not considered art, but if you as a person can truley define art then you are a god.

roger ebert says videogames are not art i personally think he feels intellectually threatened by the industry cause he doesnt truley understand the creation and "artists" behind them.  He is not a stupid guy in anyway but i do feel he has an old fashioned view and his ego is holding him back from accepting something that clearly is in the realm of art

i find salvador dali to be the most amazing artist to ever grace the earth this is my opinion , but i have also found characters and worlds in video games to be equally appealing

By the way when does the reviews gonna start coming in?

Here here!

I certainly am much better?

But the real question here is, Will it blend?

Still waiting on my house Selnor...

there are areas in uncharted 2 that beat out gow3 but they are very few and far between , overall gow3 is really something else i literally never played a game where my mouth was open in awe .  the textures are absolutely amazing for a console the scale is like nothing ive seen its really a marvel when it comes to presentation.  yes i know that crysis and metro 2033 on pc are graphics kings but what gow3 accomplishes on the console is unmatched and wont be matched till the last guardian i think .

Hello friend!! Maybe you should read this article from Eurogamer before making this thread: http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/digitalfoundry-alanwake-sub-hd-blog-entry