Lufia II by miles, even though I liked the first one a lot.

lufia 2 by far

Lufia 2, if only for that "bottomless" which the correct name of currently escapes me. The one in Lufia 1 wasn't as good, limiting by your level...

Rise of the sinistrials, I'd love to see them both on the DS :)

Lufia II is over 9000 times better than lufia 1... and it was one of my first rpg ^_^ good memories (I played lufia 1 after lufia 2 btw).

Small correction- I'd like to see both in their original style on the DS. This reimaging that S-E is doing to Lufia 2 is not faithful to the Lufia name. So as far as I'm concerned, both still need a proper port.

Lufia 1 played like a NES rpg, while Lufia 2 played like a SNEs rpg. To be honest, while I did enjoy the second game, and the original was a bit grindy, I would have to say I liked Lufia more. With that said, the topic IS better SNES game, so that means Lufia 2