OK..lets clear some shit up. I changed my vote above from theRepublic to dtewi (is that allowed ? please give me one more chance since I'm a first timer )

After Vetteman94 voted no lynch, I quoted him and said "OK then, : No Lynch". In his post he mentioned "us townies", suggesting that he is a townie...Since I'm new to mafia, I quickly edited my post thinking that he is falsely interpreting himself as a townie to make another townie slip up.

Afterwards I realized that if he WAS mafia, he would know who is a townie and who is not. So it was all a newb disaster by me.

Then I checked what everyone voted on day 1

No lynch voters

• ArkZero
• dtewi
• KingFate
• SciFiBoy
• Vetteman94

GoW_3ever

Stop editing your posts!!!!   This is how you change your vote

unvote:   name of player

vote:   name of player

I think you should go back and change your posts back to the way they were and if you want to change who you vote for, follow the above instructions.

Alsom you still havent ansered what was in the original post you edited.

I answered what was in my original post and why I edited it...

Next game, or even this game, we should probably make more of the rules explicit.  Stuff like bold your vote and don't edit should be in the OP next time for the new players.

While I know this is odd, you can go back and look at previous games that I've been in. I may have voted No Lynch once or twice, but more often than not, I didn't.

Your edit didn't bother me simply because you're a new player. New players may or may not know all of the rules, and I tend to give them a bit more leniency.

I don't quite agree with the logic that people who found your edit interesting aren't mafia. They may have wanted to bring attention to your mistake, and make you come across as mafia.

My personal suspect right now is ArkZero, because he hasn't posted much at all.

Newb disaster, or mafia disaster?  You seem very concerned with how your posts sound.  Is that because you are a calculating mafia member?

FoS: GodOfWar

(This means Finger of Suspicion.  It is shorthand for people to show who they are suspicious of.)

I just thought of one last thing.  There are 8 people today.  Since no one is going to suspect themselves, that leaves 7 suspects.  Out of 7 possible, you list 4 as your suspects.  That is over 50 percent!  That doesn't seem very helpful.  You are just slinging mud around, hoping something sticks.

Alright I am going to throw an interesting idea out there, interesting to me anyway, and I want some of your opinions on this "possible" plan. Now this is only an idea, but it could really improve our chances of finding a mafia.

I say we do a "no lynch vote today as well. Soak up as much information from posts as possible from today though. But this is how it would play out. We vote no lynch and the day ends with 8 alive. We wake up and the mafia will claim another. Leaving us with 7 people.

Then the cop comes forward and spills his guts on what he has found the first 2 days. Now that will put 3 people in the clear, unless one of his investigations nets a mafia, one being a cop, two being townies. Leaving us with 4 people left that are unconfirmed, and a possible 50/50 chance at hitting a mafia with the next day lynch, if there are only 2.

Now there can be a couple downfalls to this plan. For starters, the cop could get killed tonight which would put us in a small but not horrible situation. Another downfall would be one of the people the cop investigated gets killed, that would eliminate one of the confirmed people, but still put us in a decent spot that third day to lynch a mafia.

What do you think, its not perfect by any means, but I think it gives us a good chance of ending this by the end of day 4 with us townies winning.


I still suspect both GoW_3ever and dtewi, and wouldnt mind a lynch of one of those today, but I think this is a good alternative.

That is certainly an interesting idea. However, I think there are too many unknowns in your plan for me to be comfortable with it.

I am leaning toward there being only two mafia, but in the off chance that there are three mafia, your plan would require a mafia lynch every single day. One mis-lynch would end the game with a loss. If there are two mafia, it would take two mis-lynches.

We also don't know if the cop's first investigation is still alive. If Nikells was investigated Night One, your plan is in trouble right out of the gate.

Let's say we go through with your plan. With two mafia, there is a 17% chance the cop is killed tonight. With three mafia, there is a 20% chance the cop is killed tonight. Assuming the cop's investigation from last night is still alive, with two mafia, there is a 33% chance one of the people investigated gets killed. With three mafia, a 40% chance. So the chance of your plan getting messed up if there are two mafia is 50%. With three mafia, a 60% chance. I don't like those odds.

You state that the cop getting killed tonight would not be a horrible situation. I disagree. With two mafia, we would only get two chances to lynch before the game would end. Without any investigations, that would be tough. A 29% chance of getting mafia on the first lynch, and a 40% chance on the second. With three mafia, one mis-lynch and the game is over. The odds of getting a mafia on that one chance would be 43%.

The investigated people being killed is less troublesome. One killed would leave five unknows. So a 40% or 60% chance of getting mafia depending on how many there are. Still my biggest concern with this part of the plan is the cop's first investigation. If it was Nikells, then I think your plan is a non-starter. But I DO NOT want the cop to step forward to tell us if it was or not.

I want dtewi to post more, this is neither a vote nor FoS, it is a request, however failure to meet it, would force me to conclude that you have something to hide...

Why do you suspect Dtewi?