Mafia Round 15A - Game Thread - Vanilla Round

[theRepublic]

GodOfWar_3ever said:

Me OK..lets clear some shit up.

After Vetteman voted no lynch, I quoted him and said "OK then, : No Lynch". In his post he mentioned "us townies", suggesting that he is a townie...Since I'm new to mafia, I quickly edited my post thinking that he is falsely interpreting himself as a townie to make another townie slip up.

Afterwards I realized that if he WAS mafia, he would know who is a townie and who is not. So it was all a newb disaster by me.

Then I checked what everyone voted on day 1

After Vetteman94 voted no lynch, I quoted him and said "OK then, : No Lynch". In his post he mentioned "us townies", suggesting that he is a townie...Since I'm new to mafia, I quickly edited my post thinking that he is falsely interpreting himself as a townie to make another townie slip up.

Afterwards I realized that if he WAS mafia, he would know who is a townie and who is not. So it was all a newb disaster by me.

Newb disaster, or mafia disaster?  You seem very concerned with how your posts sound.  Is that because you are a calculating mafia member?

GodOfWar_3ever said:

I'm convinced that Vetteman94 isn't mafia judging by his first game related post. If he is, then he is EVIL. But its most likely he isn't because there is no way someone who is mafia would pretend that he is a townie like THAT.

Why wouldn't mafia pretend like that?  I'm not saying that Vetteman is mafia, but that post of his does nothing to convince me he isn't mafia.  You seem awfully sure he is a townie, when a real townie would have very few clues at this point in the game.

GodOfWar_3ever said:

theRepublic -
Didn't vote, didn't give away much at all in his posts. (Mafia probability - 55%)

You are worried that I am mafia because I did something that you did?  That seems strange.  Like you, I was not online when the day was coming to a close.  'No Lynch' only had one vote last time I was on, then the day had ended by the time I got back.  As for my posts, I said that no lynch was a good idea, but I wanted the day to go longer so I could see some more posts.  Which brings me back to this:

GodOfWar_3ever said:

What a beautiful day !

This edit does not sit well with me.  Your explanation doesn't sit well with me either.

FoS: GodOfWar

(This means Finger of Suspicion.  It is shorthand for people to show who they are suspicious of.)

I just thought of one last thing.  There are 8 people today.  Since no one is going to suspect themselves, that leaves 7 suspects.  Out of 7 possible, you list 4 as your suspects.  That is over 50 percent!  That doesn't seem very helpful.  You are just slinging mud around, hoping something sticks.