Revenge of the Sith (teh graphiczez...)
A New Hope (excellent but the terrible - by today's standards - effects pull me out of the movie)
Empire Strikes Back (nothing much to say, classic)
Return of the Jedi (Ackbar, his monkey sidekick, and those goddamn ewoks...)
Attack of the Clones (minus the story)
Teh phantom firststarwarsmoviein15years (the fight with Maul is pretty awesome, but that f***ing Jar Jar... )
Edit: the top three are pretty close. III is decent with modern graphics and some pretty cool fight/battle scenes, IV is just awesome throughout though again the effects are pretty offsetting, and I have to give major props to V for pulling off (probably) the only really good movie in cinematic history where the bad guys win