By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Killzone 2 or Halo 3?

 

Killzone 2 or Halo 3?

Killzone 2 221 54.17%
 
Halo 3 187 45.83%
 
Total:408

Definitely Halo 3.  It really is the pinnacle of first person shooters.



Around the Network
letsdance said:
sharky974 said:

Wow I'm surprised the poll is even close (so far). PS3 exclusives or the PS3 always win vgchartz polls by about 90% to 10%.

Anyways, I guess I'd say KZ2 SP is better and Halo 3 MP is better. Halo 3 was a disappointment in the Halo franchise. ODST was much better though.

Illmatic check again, when I just checked KZ2 is ahead 14 to 11.


It just cant be that the people who say this just whine to much and blow it completely out of porportion and are actually wrong about the Ps3 vs 360 fan ratio... no... that just cant be it at all


No the ratio is definately in PS3 favour. You only have to look at the viewed games section on homepage. Mag sold 300,000 first week. ME2 900,000+. Yet MAG featured above ME2 for a whole week on this site. Also look at the thread counts for M$, Sony and Nintendo. MAG isnt the only example. Just watch the most looked at games on VGChartz. You'll be lucky to have 2 360 games in there sometimes next to PS3's 6 or 7. Even if the games are critically acclaimed as not great.



selnor said:
letsdance said:
sharky974 said:

Wow I'm surprised the poll is even close (so far). PS3 exclusives or the PS3 always win vgchartz polls by about 90% to 10%.

Anyways, I guess I'd say KZ2 SP is better and Halo 3 MP is better. Halo 3 was a disappointment in the Halo franchise. ODST was much better though.

Illmatic check again, when I just checked KZ2 is ahead 14 to 11.


It just cant be that the people who say this just whine to much and blow it completely out of porportion and are actually wrong about the Ps3 vs 360 fan ratio... no... that just cant be it at all


No the ratio is definately in PS3 favour. You only have to look at the viewed games section on homepage. Mag sold 300,000 first week. ME2 900,000+. Yet MAG featured above ME2 for a whole week on this site. Also look at the thread counts for M$, Sony and Nintendo. MAG isnt the only example. Just watch the most looked at games on VGChartz. You'll be lucky to have 2 360 games in there sometimes next to PS3's 6 or 7. Even if the games are critically acclaimed as not great.


Are you kidding? Your evidence is page hits? Tell me... who is looking at these pages? Oh wait... YOU DON'T KNOW! your arguement doesnt hold water MAG could be 360 fans going "how the hell did this games sell so well... let me check here" I know for a fact my friend who only owns a 360 would be looking at MAGs page before ME2 if he were to browse this site, Everytime we work he goes and looks at MAG. On top of the fact online FPS > in popularity then RPGs

And until you have a break down of what these hits consist of you cant prove your point that way.

I know I for one vote on the polls 4 times a day in ps3s favor because I find the people who always whine incredibly funny.



letsdance said:
selnor said:
letsdance said:
sharky974 said:

Wow I'm surprised the poll is even close (so far). PS3 exclusives or the PS3 always win vgchartz polls by about 90% to 10%.

Anyways, I guess I'd say KZ2 SP is better and Halo 3 MP is better. Halo 3 was a disappointment in the Halo franchise. ODST was much better though.

Illmatic check again, when I just checked KZ2 is ahead 14 to 11.


It just cant be that the people who say this just whine to much and blow it completely out of porportion and are actually wrong about the Ps3 vs 360 fan ratio... no... that just cant be it at all


No the ratio is definately in PS3 favour. You only have to look at the viewed games section on homepage. Mag sold 300,000 first week. ME2 900,000+. Yet MAG featured above ME2 for a whole week on this site. Also look at the thread counts for M$, Sony and Nintendo. MAG isnt the only example. Just watch the most looked at games on VGChartz. You'll be lucky to have 2 360 games in there sometimes next to PS3's 6 or 7. Even if the games are critically acclaimed as not great.


Are you kidding? Your evidence is page hits? Tell me... who is looking at these pages? Oh wait... YOU DON'T KNOW! your arguement doesnt hold water MAG could be 360 fans going "how the hell did this games sell so well... let me check here" I know for a fact my friend who only owns a 360 would be looking at MAGs page before ME2 if he were to browse this site, Everytime we work he goes and looks at MAG. On top of the fact online FPS > in popularity then RPGs

And until you have a break down of what these hits consist of you cant prove your point that way.

I know I for one vote on the polls 4 times a day in ps3s favor because I find the people who always whine incredibly funny.

Well I'm smart enough to know as a 360 fan, I have never botherd clicking on those games on PS3 when they release to know the sales. The site is without a doubt lop sided. Ive been here long enough to know that. I dont think Ive seen a 360 game win a poll for 3 and a hlaf years. Even a critically acclaimed game will lose to an average one.



selnor said:
letsdance said:
selnor said:
letsdance said:
sharky974 said:

Wow I'm surprised the poll is even close (so far). PS3 exclusives or the PS3 always win vgchartz polls by about 90% to 10%.

Anyways, I guess I'd say KZ2 SP is better and Halo 3 MP is better. Halo 3 was a disappointment in the Halo franchise. ODST was much better though.

Illmatic check again, when I just checked KZ2 is ahead 14 to 11.


It just cant be that the people who say this just whine to much and blow it completely out of porportion and are actually wrong about the Ps3 vs 360 fan ratio... no... that just cant be it at all


No the ratio is definately in PS3 favour. You only have to look at the viewed games section on homepage. Mag sold 300,000 first week. ME2 900,000+. Yet MAG featured above ME2 for a whole week on this site. Also look at the thread counts for M$, Sony and Nintendo. MAG isnt the only example. Just watch the most looked at games on VGChartz. You'll be lucky to have 2 360 games in there sometimes next to PS3's 6 or 7. Even if the games are critically acclaimed as not great.


Are you kidding? Your evidence is page hits? Tell me... who is looking at these pages? Oh wait... YOU DON'T KNOW! your arguement doesnt hold water MAG could be 360 fans going "how the hell did this games sell so well... let me check here" I know for a fact my friend who only owns a 360 would be looking at MAGs page before ME2 if he were to browse this site, Everytime we work he goes and looks at MAG. On top of the fact online FPS > in popularity then RPGs

And until you have a break down of what these hits consist of you cant prove your point that way.

I know I for one vote on the polls 4 times a day in ps3s favor because I find the people who always whine incredibly funny.

Well I'm smart enough to know as a 360 fan, I have never botherd clicking on those games on PS3 when they release to know the sales. The site is without a doubt lop sided. Ive been here long enough to know that. I dont think Ive seen a 360 game win a poll for 3 and a hlaf years. Even a critically acclaimed game will lose to an average one.

You should also be smart enough to know hits mean jack shit since

A. You cant prove who those hits are coming from.

and

B. Hits don't count unique users!

I know when I'm really bored and am doing nothing I just keep hitting refresh. Like after this post I'm ging to refresh every so often waiting for your response.

And considering there are more posts on the MAG page instead of saying there are more ps3 fans Id say they are more involved.

And if you havent seen a 360 game win then you havent been active enough... since... just a few months ago I saw it. And again... that means jack shit since non members can vote and vote multiple times and vote once a day. Like I said, I have 2 computers a wii and a Ps3. I can vote on one poll 4 times a day.



Around the Network
Squilliam said:
Munkeh111 said:
Squilliam said:
Halo 3 because its got a lot more replay options, coop, 4 player local and its one of the best balanced online modes out there. Killzone 2 is really a late 80's shooter once you're over the graphics impact.

Care to explain?

They were both over-inflated due to hype anyway except Halo 3 never had as good graphics compared to the competition at the time whilst Killzone 2 got a lot of 10/10 graphics scores. So take away the graphics inflation and you have another Resistance Fall of Man 1/2 type game. A late 80s shooter along the same vein as Call of Duty 5. 

 

Hmm first I thought it was a mistake but probably I dont understand it.

 

 

The question is WHY LATE 80s ? You are talking about the decade 1980-1990 ?

 

Or do you think of something different ? 

 

Ok lets recapitulate the end of the 1980s:  NES is the leading console. First handheld with swapable games is going to be released. The Berlin Wall falls. 

David Hasselhoff is the coolest guy every for kids. Cassets are big and CDs are futuristic stuff. 

 

Killzone 2 is not related to games of that time simply because the type of games wasnt invented yet.

 

I think you mean late 90s ?

 

All FPS of today are like late 90s FPS. They havent changed the formula much. And 99% of the FPS brought nothing new to the table but still are good games. 

 

In my case I would prefer KZ2 from the atmosphere but I have to say my Halo 3 experience is pretty limited so I cant give a proper vote. 

Both games are good and deserve the sympathy. Both games are on a high level in all aspects so everything what decides is your personal taste. 

 

 

 

 

 



letsdance said:
selnor said:
letsdance said:
selnor said:
letsdance said:
sharky974 said:

Wow I'm surprised the poll is even close (so far). PS3 exclusives or the PS3 always win vgchartz polls by about 90% to 10%.

Anyways, I guess I'd say KZ2 SP is better and Halo 3 MP is better. Halo 3 was a disappointment in the Halo franchise. ODST was much better though.

Illmatic check again, when I just checked KZ2 is ahead 14 to 11.


It just cant be that the people who say this just whine to much and blow it completely out of porportion and are actually wrong about the Ps3 vs 360 fan ratio... no... that just cant be it at all


No the ratio is definately in PS3 favour. You only have to look at the viewed games section on homepage. Mag sold 300,000 first week. ME2 900,000+. Yet MAG featured above ME2 for a whole week on this site. Also look at the thread counts for M$, Sony and Nintendo. MAG isnt the only example. Just watch the most looked at games on VGChartz. You'll be lucky to have 2 360 games in there sometimes next to PS3's 6 or 7. Even if the games are critically acclaimed as not great.


Are you kidding? Your evidence is page hits? Tell me... who is looking at these pages? Oh wait... YOU DON'T KNOW! your arguement doesnt hold water MAG could be 360 fans going "how the hell did this games sell so well... let me check here" I know for a fact my friend who only owns a 360 would be looking at MAGs page before ME2 if he were to browse this site, Everytime we work he goes and looks at MAG. On top of the fact online FPS > in popularity then RPGs

And until you have a break down of what these hits consist of you cant prove your point that way.

I know I for one vote on the polls 4 times a day in ps3s favor because I find the people who always whine incredibly funny.

Well I'm smart enough to know as a 360 fan, I have never botherd clicking on those games on PS3 when they release to know the sales. The site is without a doubt lop sided. Ive been here long enough to know that. I dont think Ive seen a 360 game win a poll for 3 and a hlaf years. Even a critically acclaimed game will lose to an average one.

You should also be smart enough to know hits mean jack shit since

A. You cant prove who those hits are coming from.

and

B. Hits don't count unique users!

I know when I'm really bored and am doing nothing I just keep hitting refresh. Like after this post I'm ging to refresh every so often waiting for your response.

And considering there are more posts on the MAG page instead of saying there are more ps3 fans Id say they are more involved.


I take what you say onboard. I'm not unreasonable. Lets just agree to disagree. It's a pointless run anyway.

We are all gamers regardless. And we both know PS3 fans will click 1 option and 360 fans the other.



I dont get the point of these poll you just get the typical fanboys from each side to pick the one exclusive to their.



I like both, but KZ2 is by far better imo.



KZ2, better graphics, 32 online MP, Space Nazis