How come Metal Gear Solid 4 or Bioshock is not in this poll...

Although MGS4 is a great game it definitely didn't deserve all these 10's that it got from review sites...

Bioshock, where do I begin with this game....an OK game but not great in any way

but for the 4 games above I would say GTA IV, I enjoyed the game a lot but like MGS4 it didn't deserve a 10

Because as I said Im trying to keep exclusives out so it can stay civil.

I hate to say it But I found the SF4 mechanics to be a lil too simplistic..esp compared to SNK fighters...its still a great game though.. n RE5 was poo!

I went with MW2, I remember finishing the campaign and thinking "That's it? Really?" and all of the graon-inducing "Plot twists" that they beat us over the head with. Yeck! GTA4 is a good game, a great game actually, but how do you follow up San Andreas? Young Jeezy and Sam Jackson FTW!

Little Big Planet is overrated it starts with a great idea, but sackboy's movements sucks ass and the level editor it's not so intuitive, it takes hours to create a decent level. I've seen better editors made by amateurs like lunar magic for Super Mario World.

Resident Evil 5 and GTA 4

It's hard to pick between GTA4 and Resi 5 - which is more overrated, a 9.0 game that got 98% Meta or a 6.5 game that got 85% Meta?

Hey! That's my personal 2009 GOTY you're trashing there me boy! Them's fightin' words! *puts up his dukes*

Edit: RE5, that is.

MW2 is definitely the most overrated game. I loved CoD4 but MW2 was basically the same thing with shittier maps.

Really? And here I thought you were a reasonable man lol. It's so flawed. Biggest disappointment of 2009 IMO. I could stretch to giving it a 7 though.