Whats with this "they said" nonsense? One editor reviewed each game, this list is a collection of all the editors opinions.

kind of shows their inaccurate reviews if they have 2 games with 10's that aren't even in the top 3, either of them.

but no smash either in top 10?

anyway who cares, its just for hits anyway, ignore it

weird list

I don't know what Mirror's Edge and Prince of Persia are doing on the list. I would also seriously change some spots, but the candidated are pretty good.

Fallout 3 at the top is definitely deserved.

oh come on IGN at least have the balls to stand by your own reviews, if a 7/10 game is in the top 10 for 2008 then it must have been the worst gaming year ever, never played MGS4 but an AAA game ranked below is weird, if the 2009 GOTY is anything other than Uncharted 2 after they announced it was GOTY a month ago then I have lost all hope for IGN

I think I did enjoy Fallout 3 the most in 2008

Looks like GTA4's Oscar-worthy dialogue only got it to 3rd place.

World of Goo over MGS4 is mind-boggling... (but that's the one part I agree with, MWAHAHAHAHA.)

Best-selling fighting game of all time isn't even one of the 10 best games of the year?

Man... craziness.

this list is the dumbest thing i have ever seen

lol ign

What the hell? Not only do they put MGS4 9th, what they say about it is absolute trash.

If you look at the actual list as well : http://www.ign.com/decade/best-games-2008.html

They put every multiplat game as the 360 cover...is it just me or are they REALLY trying to piss off PS3 fanboys today?