Well at least it isn't Zack Efron. I would have boycotted the film if it was.

was zack efron seriously being considered for the job?

I have watched about a dozen of Efron's films at this point.  My wife likes him.  I actually think he is not that bad of actor now.  His first few roles were all Disney and whatever.  I wouldn't have any problem with him.  The Pettyfer guy isn't much of an actor for sure.

The old trilogy had one big advantage. The main cast was mostly unknown besides Alec Guinness. nobody had any expectations. or dislikes.

I don't know who these people are.... granted, the internet didn't exist back then, so I couldn't google and youtube and form my opinion in 10 minutes :P.