Who had the best E3 keynote?

[DirtyP2002]

DMeisterJ said:
People must understand that Megaton =/= good Keynote.

MS had a megaton.

The other ninety minutes of it sucked majorly. Showed games we all saw, then focused on casuals for 1 hour.

Sony on the other hand, showed games we hadn't seen, got through all the corporate gloating in a very fun way, and paced the conference so I wasn't bored during it.

 

 Okay R2 and LBP for PS3 were the only games we actually saw. The socom stuff was just a rendered trailer, same for god of war. These games were announced, not shown. There aren't any release-dates, are there?

MS had the greatest announcement with FF XIII, there is no doubt about it. AND they actually showed Gears of War or Fable2. They showed Fallout3 and announced the exclusive download content. Besides that Universal NBC supporting Xbox Live Video Marketplace is huge, Netflix is, for the US, even bigger.

Nintendo was very bad. There was nothing I could look forward to.

 

So:

MS won with 7.5 / 10

Sony second with 6 / 10

Nintendo lost with 2 / 10