I think they all failed on some level, meaning there was no stand out, how do you clearly define a winner.
M$ stole, rapped and pillaged their way to a conference.
Nintendo innovated but forgot the core gamers.
Sony went around in circles and sold everyone with a video of GOW3.
But to have to choose, i would say
sony > M$ > Nintendo
and Im a Nintendo fanboy.
That said MotionPlus, WS:R has me more interested then any title from either Sony or M$. I also think if nintendo spent 10 minutes showing other games that are being revealed at the show they would of come away clear winners. It hard to win when your focus is gameplay.
Nintendo = Innovation = Wii







