Sony only won if you're a fan of shooters. LBP was not amazing. No new RPG's shown (Folklore is out and bombed in Japan). GT5 was only CG.
Killzone 2 looked great and MGS did as well, but I had the feeling Sony only wanted to beat Microsoft in a "maturity" contest instead of showing why all 360 (and Wii60) owners are wrong. Cause even though MS had a bad show, the games were there and people will buy Halo either way, no matter how good Killzone looks, they played Rockband live (was bad but entertaining), showed Blue Dragon. Unreal is a PC game and people won't run to the store to buy a PS3 to play NBA08. Put in the horrible peresentation skills and the best sentence of the show: "That's enough Motorstorm for a day" after 30 seconds playing it and it is clear that Sony had only 2 outstanding games to show, which may have won them the show, but I don't think they demolished MS which they could and should have.
I'm not even talking bout Wii, since they showed two instant multi-million sellers (Fit, MK).







