By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
CourageTCD said:
crissindahouse said:

There's also people who say Goldeneye on N64, Metal Gear Solid from PS One or Chrono Trigger from SNES are the best games of all time and none of them would even get a Metascore of 70 if they would release nowadays.

OoT is the greatest game of all time for many and the remake is the definitive version of that game and a 9.5 for nowadays standards (in their opinion) but people say "greatest game of all time" because of the N64 game they loved so much in 1998 even though almost nobody could play the game more than an hour nowadays. 

Without the OoT remake you wouldn't call OoT "a really bad game" just because it sucks for nowadays standards with the bad controls and so on. It's pretty simple

I didn't get what you are trying to explain. Besides, what about their giving 10 to a "not pefect game"? This is a two-sided problem, and you just tackled (although I didnt understand what you were saying) just one half of it

What I tried to explain was that OoT is considered by many as the best game of all time and yet it wouldn't even get a Metascore of 70 if you would review the N64 version nowadays. But that obviously doesn't stop the reviewer to call it the best game of all time. That editor could have reviewed the remake with a 8.5 and still say that it's the definitive version of the best game of all time. 

If you think a car from the 80s is the best car ever made than it also doesn't mean it is by any means as good as any car from 2026. But many will still call that car from the 80s the best of all time because of what it achieved in the 80s.