By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Vinther1991 said:
angrypoolman said:

This score is a result of hype and marketing. Nothing more.

What? You don't believe that GTA VI is the first piece of entertainment in human history that EVERYONE agrees is a masterpiece?
It's a result of hype, it's a result of outlets handing over review duties to staff that are already fans of the IP, and it's a result of conforming to popular opinion to avoid threats and slander. And then of course it is also a result of Rockstar making a seemingly well crafted game.

GTA IV is a game I love, and to me the highlight of the series, but even I have to admit that 98 on Metacritic is not an honest score. If it was it would consistently rank in the top 10 whenever a major outlet posts their lists of greatest games of all time, it almost never even makes the top 100s anymore, since GTA V came out, which in turn won't make any list in the future, now that GTA VI is out. 

Everything said here is correct. Rockstar obviously outdid themselves, looks like a quality product barring framerate, but 99 based on 140 reviews, we know what is going on here. I got platinum trophy on GTA IV, so I am as qualified as anybody to speak on this, the game is far from a 98. And I was 19 when it released in 2008. It is clearly overrated. Same thing is happening here. 



Total Championships: Nintendo - 4, Sony - 2, Atari - 1, Microsoft - 0, Sega - 0