By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Bofferbrauer2 said:
HoloDust said:

It did, in its original incarnation - LoZ was designed as item gated open world. Strip away open world and it becomes linear puzzle solving affair, like SS. Strip away item gated progression and it becomes BotW.

I don't find either of those extremes to be good for the IP in the long run and going back to original LoZ formula (augmented by some of the newer mechanics) would cater to both fan bases.

To some degree, BotW also has Item progression, even though it's mostly limited to the great plateau, where Link gets his Sheikah powers and the glider, but later those also get enhanced with the right ingredients at the two labs. Plus, the tunics with their different power-ups. And all the things you can cook. And the powers you get from defeating the blight Ganons in the the mythical beasts.

It's just not predetermined items that lock you out on things, as you can do without them - but it's gonna a be helluva lot more difficult.

Great Plateau is tutorial, so it kinda makes sense. But actual game after that has no gating, and Zelda always had some sort of gating and was never completely open. Take away that (like BotW did) and fundamental pillar of Zelda is gone.

If Zelda is to retain its original identity, while retaining fans of BotW approach, they need to come up with something that is much, much better than BotW formula, while not completely going back to classic 3D Zelda design. (I'm sure you can, just like me, come up with plethora of solutions, but that's another topic).