By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

In terms of my preferred console, Xbox 360 is the winner. Superior controller, better collection of first-party games, and more reliable performance when it comes to big third-party games.

In terms of legacy, PS3 is the winner. While Xbox 360 performed well from a software perspective between 2005 and 2010, it fell off fast starting around 2011. Yes, Microsoft crapped the bed with the Xbox One launch, but that launch didn’t emerge from a vacuum. I think the early success of Kinect on 360 really hurt the future of Xbox gaming.

Sony, conversely, used this period to build up its brand. At a time when Xbox was investing in Kinect and mismanaging its flagship franchise, PlayStation was reaping the rewards of its investment in first-party content. Now, personally, I think the shift toward filmic/arthouse games that prioritize graphics, emotional resonance, and narrative was a mistake, but there’s no denying the appeal among consumers. And Sony used that appeal (and Microsoft’s self-inflicted wounds) to catapult the PS4 to great success.