Sid’s was funnier, IMO.
Hogan’s was worse, but not specifically because of the “gay guy” part, but because he kept tripping over words and was kind of longwinded. Former WWF Champion The Iron Sheik already confirmed many times that “Jabrobi Hulk Hogan” was gay.
Speaking of Iron Sheik, he botched a promo too saying that he was, and I quote: “Going to put Hogan in the camel clutch! Beak his back! Fuck his ass! And make him humble!” Howard Stern brought him on later pointing out that it sounded like Iron Sheik admitted to being gay for wanting to fuck Hogan in the ass, and Iron Sheik clarified “No-no-no! I don’t mean fuck his ass with my dick. I meant with a broken beer bottle! So it is not gay like Michael Jackson, and uh… British guy Elton John!”
Robyn confirmed that fucking in the ass with a beer bottle wasn’t gay.
https://youtu.be/1APM6t1ASqw?si=0PoQQshUbB17Qmti
I describe myself as a little dose of toxic masculinity.
