You Can Only Choose One – Top Ten Highest Rated Games on MetaCritic (as of May 2026)

[drbunnig]

SanAndreasX said:

Veknoid_Outcast said:

Weirdly, this is easy for me, even though six of these are in my top 50 (with four in my top 20). But Breath of the Wild is just so amazing that it has a way of overshadowing the greatness of other games.

I'd pick SoulCalibur second and Super Mario Galaxy 2 third.

I'd have picked Breath of the Wild, but it wasn't an option here, so I went with Twilight Princess.

I'm not seeing Twilight Princess on the list...