By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Cerebralbore101 2 days ago
Edit Thread
sc94597 said:
Pemalite said:

Sorry. That is blatantly false.

I can still put my Windows 98 StarCraft: Brood Wars CD into my USB external Blu-Ray drive on my modern Windows 11 PC and install and run the game perfectly fine, despite being 27 years old.

Likewise, I can still put my original Age of Empires (1997) CD from 2002 that I got in a Kellogs cereal box and run it perfectly fine from disk.

I have Commander Keen on floppy disk, which I can install from my USB floppy drive, that's a game that released for DOS in 1990, 36 years ago.

These are games that are older than Steam. And will continue to be perfectly operational for years to come.

PC is a platform that is contiguous, it doesn't have "Generational breaks" the same as console, besides OS changes, which can have work around's for backwards compatibility (I.E. DosBox), which exists regardless if it's digital or physical.

I am not getting in this is argument with you given our prior discussions and your tendency toward inflexible black and white thinking. 

But no it isn't blatantly false that I can more easily play a digital version of games released in 2004 on most current hardware than it is to play a disc version that depends on me accessing an optical drive in the year 2026. I am not carrying a fricken external optical drive everywhere I go with my laptop.

And that is without considering compatibility issues that Steam streamlines and reduces.

This is my last post on this topic in response to you. Already seen where it is going with language like "blatantly false." 

You are both sort of right. On one hand he can play his physical games. On the other hand playing them via a software emulator instead of a period-correct PC is like slapping an original NES cart into one of those crappy $25 NES clones that retrobit or hyperkin puts out. It's just not authentic or accurate anymore. Might as well run an emulator with a digital rom, because without the original hardware or an fpga solution it's not going to run right.