By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
JackHandy said:
JWeinCom said:

Ok... but I dont see the problem with that? We're not doing science here. Ita just for discussion. If people are getting hung up on technicalities thats kind of on them.

People are too subjectively driven, so if you want concrete answers, you have to think ahead and make sure you plan for it. This thread ended up solving nothing. I mean, someone mentioned Sonic the Hedgehog, for crying out loud. EGM gave it literal 9's across the board (and one reviewer scored it above SMW). It, and it's three successors were titanic, industry-changing phenomena. If  that doesn't defeat the purpose of his thread, I don't know what does.

I like seeing people's thoughts and give people something to talk about. I purposefully left some room for subjectivity in order to not rule out so many franchises that it kills off most discussion before it even starts. Admittedly I'm not closely familiar with all the franchises mentioned here, but I feel like the responses here have generally belonged well enough to this thread, so personally I'm pretty happy with it.

CourageTCD said:

Just Dance. The first entry had lackluster routines and the music selection wasn't so interesting in general

Oh wow, a metascore of 49? No surprise it got a sequel (and then some) with those sales, but that's a great pick for this thread!