The Discussion Thread -Day #7- The 15th Annual Greatest Games Event

[Runa216]

Darashiva said:

#9

Change YoY: +1   My Rating: 9.6/10

Elden Ring is not only the best game of this generation so far, but also the best open world game I've ever played by a decent margin. Initially upon hearing about the game, I wasn't entirely convinced that the soulsborne formula would translate well into an open world. The FromSoftware-developed titles were, among other things, known for their intricately designed, interconnected locations that wrapped around each other in various clever ways that made exploration a joy to undertake. Taking a game like that and placing it into and open world setting admittedly felt a little odd at first. However, as it turns out, they still created those same wonderfully designed locations and simply made them part of the larger world in Elden Ring. Best of both worlds I suppose.

The thing that hit me first about the game, at least once I made my way through the introductory dungeon and opened that first door into the open world, was just how gorgeous it looked. There may be games with better graphics from a pure technological point of view, but no other game in a long time has looked this great in terms of art direction. The next thing that hit me was a lance from a miniboss riding a horse, followed by the first of many death screens. Like meeting an old friend. After a while I got into the right rhythm, taking my time exploring, finding intriguing places and enemies, and slowly mapping out the first area of the game. As the world began to open up more and I got used to game's intricacies and differences from previous FromSoftware titles, I realized just how well it all worked together. Putting the developer's style into an open world setting had done nothing to hamper the experience, and in a lot of ways it only enhanced it. This was an open world done right.

There was a sense of wonder and mystery that remained with me throughout the over 130 hours I spent playing Elden Ring on my first playthrough. I never got tired of discovering new locations, dungeons, bosses, secrets, and details about the world. It felt like there was something new and exciting to be found no matter where I went and how long I played. Even now, after finishing the game and spending so much time with it, I've seen other players find entire dungeons and bosses I never encountered in the game. The game is so full of stuff, and unlike in so many other open world games, it's all engaging and interesting. No pointless fetch quests or worthless collectibles that mean nothing. While there are some minor faults to be found, such as certain bosses being repeated a few too many times, I have never enjoyed an open world as much as I did The Lands Between. Elden Ring was the first new game to enter my gaming top ten in five years, when another FromSoftware game entered into it, which I will be talking about very soon.

Then, came Shadow of the Erdtree, and my opinion on the game as a whole only improved. Not only was it another absolutely massive piece of content to add to an already huge title, but much of it is arguably even better than the base game. New enemies, weapons, skills, bosses, and locations, as well as lore and storylines that expand on elements from the main game and reveals new information about many characters you were already familiar with, first and foremost being Miquella. There's a chance that in the future Elden Ring will rise even higher on my list upon repeat playthroughs, as that is what happened to many of the other FromSoftware games. Until then, it sits firmly in my all-time top 10, and is unlikely to fall out any time soon.

I'm like 20 runs into the game across multiple platforms, modded and unmodded, PS4, PS5, PC, solo, coop, etc....and I'm more excited to play the game now than I Was two years ago. There's just so much build variety and so many ways to play the game. 

I've already put like 1500 hours into the game and every few weeks I get the urge to try something new. And I Feel like in spite of all that I've only scraped the surface in terms of what can be done with Elden RIng's mechanics. 

And even better...playing it made me go back and play Dark Souls III again and I like DS3 more now that I better understand infusions and weapon arts! You know a game is great when it gets better with time AND makes you like other games even more than you did before. 

Bloodborne is still higher on my list but I have to confess...might just be for nostalgia purposes. Because honestly, I think Elden Ring is the better game. Bloodborne was my first Soulslike game I finished and the first one I fell in love with and nostalgia is a valid emotion. Aside from some quality of life shit (30 FPS and some of the crap you gotta do to travel and level up, etc) it holds up remarkably well! Elden Ring and Bloodborne are both outstanding games that I recommend pretty much everyone at least TRY.