The third console curse: Which was the biggest stumble?

[Darwinianevolution]

Soundwave said:

Darwinianevolution said:

Really, the Saturn takes the cake on this hands down. It sealed the fate of Sega's hardware and allowed its competition to dominate handily. The real question is what's second.
XBOne has damaged the XBox brand in a similar way, but it hasn't threatened to derail the entirety of MS Gaming (MS gaming is too big for XBox's failure to really impact it).
The PS3 was a money sinkhole that burnt all previous PS profits and nearly bankrupt Sony, but afterwards the PS4 kept its dominance and they recovered their losses for the most part.
The N64's high price and cartriges allowed the PS to thrive, but Nintendo was very safe with the GameBoy's dominance, so it was really in no danger at all (a situation that continued with the GC-GBA).

The Game Boy's "dominance" was a bit of a fluke as the Game Boy was in major decline by the mid-1990s. When people say "what the fuck was Nintendo thinking with the Virtual Boy" ... it was because Game Boy sales were sliding down the tubes and Yamauchi basically ordered Yokoi to make something else to sell. 

Pokemon came out of nowhere and gave the Game Boy a second lease on life, but this basically never happens in the industry. 

Nintendo's position would have been precarious without that, they didn't plan for the Game Boy getting that second wind at all. 

Oh sure, Pokemon was a miracle for Nintendo at the moment. But the fact of the matter is that even without Pokemon, Nintendo still had no true competition over the handheld market, so the pressure was much less than for Sega, which had no real competitive alternative for either market, with both the Game Gear and the Saturn failing.