shikamaru317 on 08 September 2024
- For Quantic Dream I liked Fahrenheit and Detroit, but I've never played Heavy rain and found Two Souls to be meh. We've also heard they are having huge behind the scenes issues on their upcoming Star Wars game.
- Supermassive did a fantastic job on Until Dawn. Dark Pictures started rough but has improved with each game in the series (though I haven't experience the latest one yet). The Quarry was generally better than Dark Pictures but still didn't come close to Until Dawn. Haven't played Casting of Frank Stone yet but I love Dead By Daylight so I'll grab it in a sale at some point.
- Telltale started pretty well with games like BTTF The Game and of course The Walking Dead season 1, but they have been very hit and miss ever since, some good games like Tales from the Borderlands, Walking Dead Season 2, and Wolf Among Us, but also some misses like Game of Thrones, Walking Dead Michonne, and Walking Dead: A New Frontier. The company eventually went belly up from spreading themselves too thin and trying to do to many games at once while never fixing their engine issues. They were later revived and are now trying to finish Wolf Among Us 2.
Overall I'll go with Supermassive > Telltale > Quantic Dream.
