By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
pikashoe on 03 August 2024
Edit Thread
Valdney said:
Mar1217 said:

Ok, your opinion was already made clear in another thread, if you want to further that, it'd be preferred that you make another thread on the NSMBU vs Wonder game design subject. 

Also, stating something of this nature while NSMBU was released for much longer(4 years) than Wonder who hasn't even completed its first year yet is presumptuous. The game will get it's boost as any evergreen during the holiday season while continuing to sell during this current year. Not withstanding additional sales coming during the beginning of the Switch 2 lifespan. 

Whenever someone says that MW is a really good game and it is not selling well enough because of any other reason than it actually not being a good 2d Mario game I will rebuke it as many times as I want. 

Now, it is not presumptuous at all to say that about NSMBU because I am basing it off of quarterly reports. The same could be said about BotW vs TotK. Why has Nintendo not updated MW numbers? Because the numbers are probably embarrassingly low.  

I do admit that I root for Nintendo almost as much as I root for my football club. I want its games to succeed and break sales records, that is why I criticize it when IMO their games fall in quality.

The game is critically acclaimed and user reviews are also extremely high. It has extremely positive WoM. You might not like the game but to say that reception of the game is anything but stellar is just factually incorrect. The only reason it wasn't updated was that it is not in the top 10 yet and didn't sell 1 million during the quarter. It's likely going by sales numbers we've seen that it is selling on par with other evergreen titles at the moment.

I agree that you should make a thread comparing the games, it would be interesting to compare and contrast the games.