By the way, here is how 2016 GOTY worked out at the time according to a GOTY tracker, based on total number of awards won by each game, for all games that got at least 2 GOTY awards:
Uncharted 4: A Thief's End - 165
- The Critics' Picks - 89
- The Readers' Picks - 76
Overwatch - 102
- The Critics' Picks - 90
- The Readers' Picks - 12
DOOM - 29
- The Critics' Picks - 26
- The Readers' Picks - 3
Battlefield 1 - 16
- The Critics' Picks - 6
- The Readers' Picks - 10
The Last Guardian - 15
- The Critics' Picks - 15
INSIDE - 12
- The Critics' Picks - 12
Dark Souls III - 12
- The Critics' Picks - 9
- The Readers' Picks - 3
Final Fantasy XV - 9
The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt - Blood and Wine - 9
Dishonored 2 - 8
The Witness - 7
Titanfall 2 - 5
Hitman - 3
Pokémon GO - 3
XCOM 2 - 3
SUPERHOT - 2