By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

This was a phenomenal year, with all three consoles delivering the goods.

With so many terrific games it's a tough call, but ultimately I have to go with Super Mario Galaxy 2. From its wildly imaginative game design to its divine music, it's a worthy followup to its legendary predecessor.

Also, I feel like Halo Reach deserved to be one of the nominees here.