At the time I probably would've opted for Uncharted 2, but that series hasn't aged so well for me. My pick now is Left 4 Dead 2.
I have yet to play Demon's Souls; that could've been a contender for me, since I love the Souls series. I'm still hoping the remake comes to PC one day...
Lots of good titles in the 'other' list too - I particularly have a soft spot for the Halo Wars and Trials series.
Last edited by Machina - on 16 November 2023