I'm guessing the 6 GOTY nominations at Keighley's The Game Awards 2023 will be Zelda, Baldur's Gate 3, Starfield, Spider-Man, Street Fighter 6, and FF16. Of those, I suspect that either Spider-Man or FF16 will have the lowest reviews, but hard to say at this point which of the two, as Spider-Man 1 got an 87 and Spider-Man Miles Morales got an 85, both lower than FF16's 88, but the sequel could do better than the previous 2 games.
As for the overall Game of the Year tracking that you see on sites like GameAwards.net and goty.gamefa.com, you will see the highly reviewed games that got snubbed by Keighley's show doing a bit better on the rankings there, games like HiFi Rush, Resident Evil 4 remake, and Dead Space remake.