By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Ryuu96 said:
LurkerJ said:

I don't feel strongly about how you want to handle this. But wouldn't a title edit is better than an outright lock? The majority won't support the claim of this being a scandal (lol), and the few who believe it is, might end up changing their minds reading the reasonable counter arguments.

That's an interesting perspective, that now has me thinking, Lol.

My issue is mostly that it's a bit of a low quality thread, not only damaging to our credibility as a website but also feeling like it's an attack towards the judge, I don't want to help spread this conspiracy theory that she's biased and cause others to attack her, if this wasn't about an individual but something else (like flat earth) then I might let people get their ribbing in first, Lmao, but I would still lock it later because I'd rather just stamp the conspiracy theories out.

It's mostly that it's a person here that I am so reactive, even though nobody here may do it, I imagine a lurker seeing this thread (some console warrior) and then spreading it on Twitter, then another dude spreads it, and another, then then we have a bunch of angry console warriors attacking the judge on Twitter over some stupid conspiracy theory but if I'm being honest, they're doing that already, so I guess the argument is do we leave conspiracy theory threads up.

Maybe I'll change the title while we have this conversation, Lol.

First of all, thanks for engaging. 

I think "flat earth" vs "judge's son works for X company" are a bit different, legal proceedings and court dealings are uncharted territory for most, including me. I certainly have said things months ago about the case that I would cringe hard reading them now. So while "judge's son works for x" makes for a flashy headlines that didn't fool me, I can see why others might fall for it, it's just not public knowledge.

Keeping the door open for discussions can be educational, I have already learned a new thing reading other posts on here, make of what you will.