The indoor lighting lets it down a bit, it looks too uniform, and the way the torch casts light looks fake, for example in the dark it only illuminates a direct circle, whereas in real life the bounce lighting would indirectly illuminate all around.
That said, I do like the way it's going for a hyper-realistic presentation. Playing as a cop shooting people in a realistic way though is gonna really anger a lot of people, though as always the outcry will only give it free publicity, just like No Russian did back in 2009.