The Metroid Prime Remastered approach vs the Resident Evil 4 Remake approach

[Chrkeller]

curl-6 said:

I feel like I didn't word this one effectively; my bad.
What I meant was less "which is the better game" but rather "which do you think is the better approach to reviving a classic game, a complete design a la RE4R, or a graphical rebuild that keeps the design intact a la Prime Remastered".

Depends on the game.  I mean something like RE2 aged horribly, especially the controls, thus it needs to be rebuilt.  Something like Prime aged wonderfully so it only needed upgrades.  So it depends on the game.