By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
RolStoppable said:
burninmylight said:

By that logic, every single old game that exists in a genre with modern equivalents is overrated because time, technology and mastery of the medium allows new games that are merely decent to often be better than masterpieces of decades ago. At this point, every single FPS worth your time should be better than GoldenEye, and every 3D platformer should be better than BK, not counting nontechnical factors like plot and presentation. The only things that aren't overrated are... Seaman? Cubivore? Odama? Vib Ribbon?

They are rating these games just fine. No one in here is claiming that quarter-century old N64 games stand up to modern greats like A Hat in Time or Insert FPS Here.

Seriously? A Hat in Time belongs to the pile of overrated indie games. Its worlds are way too big and they are more often than not poorly designed.

A modern great is Super Mario Odyssey. You cannot seriously believe that A Hat in Time is a good game, let alone a great one. I don't think you played it; you just go by what you've read from others. It must be. Your judgment can't be this poor.

I guess most people's judgement is poor, since the PS4 version for example got a 79 metascore and 8.7 userscore. Dude, an opinion is an opinion.

Last edited by Kakadu18 - on 03 February 2022