Dulfite on 10 November 2021
| Rank | Title | Platform(s) | Developer | Year | YoY |
| #50 | Assassin's Creed IV: Black Flag | Wii U | Ubisoft | 2013 | -20 |
| #49 | The Legend of Zelda: Minish Cap | Gameboy Advance | Nintendo | 2004 | -20 |
| #48 | Portal | PC | Valve | 2007 | -20 |
| #47 | Portal 2 | PC | Valve | 2011 | -20 |
| #46 | Underhero | Switch |
Paper Castles Games |
2018 | -20 |
| #45 | Luigi's Mansion | GameCube | Nintendo | 2001 | New |
| #44 | Dragon Quest 11 | Switch | Square Enix | 2007 | -19 |
| #43 | Donkey Kong Country 2 | SNES | Nintendo/Rare | 1995 | -19 |
| #42 | Super Mario 64 | N64 | Nintendo | 1996 | -19 |
| #41 | Final Fantasy 7 | Switch | Square Enix | 1997 | New |
| #40 | Super Mario World | SNES | Nintendo | 1990 | -18 |
| #39 | Advance Wars | GBA | Nintendo | 2001 | New |
| #38 | Super Paper Mario | Wii | Nintendo | 2007 | New |
| #37 | Batman: Arkham Asylum | PC | WB Interactive | 2009 | -16 |
| #36 | Xenoblade Chronicles 2 | Switch | Nintendo | 2017 | -16 |
| #35 | Lego City Undercover | Wii U | TT Games | 2013 | -16 |
| #34 | Animal Crossing New Horizons | Switch | Nintendo | 2020 | -16 |
| #33 | Dragon Quest 1 | Switch | Square Enix | 1986 | New |
| #32 | Luigi's Mansion 3 | Switch | Nintendo (now owns Next Level Games) | 2019 | New |
| #31 | Warcraft 2 | PC | Blizzard | 1995 | New |
| #30 | The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild | Switch | Nintendo | 2017 | -14 |
| #29 | Shovel Knight | Wii U | Yacht Club Games | 2014 | -14 |
| #28 | Mario Kart 8 Deluxe | Switch | Nintendo | 2017 | -14 |
| #27 | The Outer Worlds | PC | Private Division (Xbox Games) | 2019 | -14 |
| #26 | Middle-Earth: Shadow of Mordor | PC | WB Interactive | 2014 | -14 |
| #25 | Pokemon Diamond/Pearl/Platinum | DS | Gamefreak | 2006 | New |
| #24 | Red Alert 2 | PC | Westwood | 2000 | New |
| #23 | Pokemon Red/Blue/Yellow | GB | Gamefreak | 1996 | New |
| #22 | Super Smash Bros. | N64 | Nintendo | 1999 | New |
| #21 | Halo 4 | PC | Microsoft | 2012 | New |
| #20 | Star Fox 64 | N64 | Nintendo | 1997 | -10 |
| #19 | Mario + Rabbids: Kingdom Battle | Switch | Ubisoft | 2017 | -10 |
| #18 | Mario Kart 64 | N64 | Nintendo | 1996 | New |
| #17 | Mario Kart Doubledash | GameCube | Nintendo | 2003 | New |
| #16 | 007 Goldeneye | N64 | RARE | 1995 | New |
| #15 | Advance Wars 2 | GBA | Nintendo | 2003 | New |
| #14 | Mario Kart Wii | Wii | Nintendo | 2008 | New |
| #13 | Celeste | Switch | Matt Makes Games | 2018 | -5 |
| #12 | The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword | Wii | Nintendo | 2011 | -5 |
| #11 | Hyrule Warriors | Switch | Nintendo | 2014 | -5 |
| #10 | Prey | PC | Microsoft | 2017 | New |
| #9 | Halo 2 | PC | Microsoft | 2004 | New |
| #8 | Warhammer: Total War | PC | SEGA | 2016 | -4 |
| #7 | Banjo Tooie | N64 | Rare | 2000 | New |
| #6 | Star Wars: Rogue Squadron II | GameCube | Factor 5 | 2001 | New |
| #5 | Pokemon Silver/Gold/Crystal | GBC | The Pokemon Company | 2000 | New |
| #4 | Super Smash Bros. Melee | GameCube | Nintendo | 2001 | New |
| #3 | Bug Fable | Switch | Dangen Entertainment | 2019 | 0 |
| #2 | Batman: Arkham City | Wii U | WB Interactive | 2011 | 0 |
| #1 | Paper Mario The Thousand Year Door | GameCube | Nintendo | 2004 | 0 |
Essay Pro