Uncharted 2 was the high point. Everything was superbly balanced, great story, locations, the smoothest gameplay, it all came together.
Uncharted 3 is not that far behind, I particularly liked how in that game the story was a bit less ‘otherworldly’. Uncharted 4 though was, while good, a bit more of the same so that was a slight disappointment, and it dragged on for too long. I think I still like it more than the original, which, while I think put the PS3 on the map, is less memorable to me.
I actually liked Golden Abyss a lot, it wasn’t any less than its console brethren, and it did collectables better than any of them. I probably would rank it above 4 simply because I thought it was a relatively better game for what it was than Uncharted 4 was. Lost Abyss though was a bit dull to me, I mean some things were entertaining and the elephant scene was stylish, but I was glad the game was over.
Ranked it would be;
1. Uncharted 2
2. Uncharted 3
3. Uncharted Golden Abyss
4. Uncharted 4
6. Uncharted Lost Legacy
Bonus: I like the series so I hope there’ll be another. Could be a big reason to get me to get a PS5. Basically I would be fine with more of the same, which I know is contradictory to what I said about 4, so rather; I would be fine with more of what made the others good, but new. I expect though that a next game will just pick up where 4 ended, with a big role for you know who.