Games that were graphically impressive for their time, but are ugly now.

[curl-6]

I still think the PS3/360 titles that had an appealing visual identity and were technically sound still look good today.

Stuff like Bioshock 1/2/Infinite, Uncharted 2/3, Halo 4/Reach, Dead Space, the Gears of War games, RE5, Puppeteer, etc.