Personal Best game in Genres

[Azzanation]

JustThatGamer said:

Why ask people to list their favourite games in certain genres and then list an arbitrary Metascores which are based on other peoples opinions? Seems counter-intuitive to me, anyway a quick list off the top of my head:

Action-Adventure: God of War 2018
Action: God of War III
FPS: BioShock
TPS: Gears of War 2
Platformer: LittleBigPlanet 2
Racing: Gran Turismo 4
Arcade Racer: PGR4
Fighting: Tekken Tag 2
Thriller: Alan Wake
ARPG: Mass Effect 2
RPG: Skyrim
Run & Gun: Cuphead

Why not?

Curious to know what people see in games that can and connot favor critics.