I think every website/blog is entitled to post it's own Game of the Year, and therefore all sorts of games can win depending on the individual. However if you are thinking about the blog that keeps track of which game gets the most Game of the Year awards, it is usually a AAA, cinematic, M-Rated, action game. Occasionally, the game is not M-Rated to show that the gaming critics have a lot of breadth to their tastes.