RDR2 was great, as long as you ignored the story missions :/
And if you're not in a hurry to get somewhere
It deserves a special mention for the bounty mechanism, undermining whatever game play opportunities it offered.
GT Sport falls in this category too now ever since PD totally abandoned improving the penalty system. It's been in shambles since early this year and turned into Forza online. I quit the game a couple months ago after playing it daily since release.